Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Arne Keller
At 21:47 22-03-2004 -0500, Roman Turovsky wrote: I was wondering if the Baroque Lute D minor tuning is/was ever used for Bass Continuo playing? Tim Mills A number of people do it, including myself, although I don't like the idea. RT Sounds strange. Please explain. Also, how did Merville tune

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Roman Turovsky
At 21:47 22-03-2004 -0500, Roman Turovsky wrote: I was wondering if the Baroque Lute D minor tuning is/was ever used for Bass Continuo playing? Tim Mills A number of people do it, including myself, although I don't like the idea. RT Sounds strange. Please explain. Arne. IMO: Baroque Lute

Re: also....

2004-03-23 Thread Tim Kuntz
Now I'm confused. Didn't Stewart (and others) identify a theorbo as a lute with re-entrant tunings? So if one avoids re-entrant tunings, is it still a theorbo? Tim Kuntz - Original Message - From: Roman Turovsky [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: David Rastall [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: LUTE-LIST

Bass strings

2004-03-23 Thread Eugene Ivanov
Hello, I'm a novice Renaissance lute player, a recent convert from classical guitar, so please excuse my ignorance. I'm trying to find the right bass strings and get a good bass sound on a REnaissance lute. I tried Nylegut (didn't like that at all), loaded gut from Aquila, gimped and metal

Re: also....

2004-03-23 Thread Roman Turovsky
Weiss theorbo is an exception. RT __ Roman M. Turovsky http://turovsky.org http://polyhymnion.org Now I'm confused. Didn't Stewart (and others) identify a theorbo as a lute with re-entrant tunings? So if one avoids re-entrant tunings, is it still a theorbo? Tim Kuntz -

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Jerzy ZAK
On Tuesday, Mar 23, 2004, at 14:40 Europe/Warsaw, Roman Turovsky wrote: .. IMO: Baroque Lute is ill-suited to any group endeavor, excepted accompanying a single voice singing maximum at mezza voce. It is destined to be a PRIVATE instrument, like clavichord, as I said elsewhere. What is

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Roman Turovsky
IMO: Baroque Lute is ill-suited to any group endeavor, excepted accompanying a single voice singing maximum at mezza voce. It is destined to be a PRIVATE instrument, like clavichord, as I said elsewhere. What is private and what is public in terms of 18th C. and 21st C. --? Very complicated

Re: Re: also....

2004-03-23 Thread corun
Tim wrote: Now I'm confused. Didn't Stewart (and others) identify a theorbo as a lute with re-entrant tunings? So if one avoids re-entrant tunings, is it still a theorbo? I've just started reading Nigel North's continuo book and in the first chapter he lists several tunings for theorbo,

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread uso56dk
Citat Roman Turovsky [EMAIL PROTECTED]: OK Roman, I see your point. But what about Merville? Anyone else? What tuning did he use? Anxiously, Arne.

Re: also....

2004-03-23 Thread Roman Turovsky
Please note: I moved this thread to the Baroque-Lute List where this might profit from slightly different demographics. RT __ Roman M. Turovsky http://turovsky.org http://polyhymnion.org

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Jerzy ZAK
On Tuesday, Mar 23, 2004, at 19:40 Europe/Warsaw, Roman Turovsky wrote: ... someone else's execrable music (like Hasse's for example). RT ... I fail to recall any of his music RT ... Sugar as an anti-depressant??? Not for me. RT I perfectly understand your point. How you can like

Beg. question, voicing 4-note chords.

2004-03-23 Thread Herbert Ward
My teacher and I are working on four-note chords, using all four right-hand fingers (p, i, m, and a). I had the practice piece sounding OK (at my student tempo). But then my teacher wanted me to keep my right-hand little finger in contact with (or very close to) the soundboard, and not pull

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Howard Posner
Roman Turovsky at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: IMO: Baroque Lute is ill-suited to any group endeavor, excepted accompanying a single voice singing maximum at mezza voce. You're playing continuo whether you're accompanying 1 voice or 100. Existence of fine chamber music with Baroque Lute does not

Re: Beg. question, voicing 4-note chords.

2004-03-23 Thread arielabramovich
Dear Herbert, I'm afraid I'll disagree with your teacher, with respect. Having the little finger in the soundboard is fine, and very useful for different reasons. On the other hand, you should be able to play with the right arm as free as possible (specially while playing

RE: Bass strings

2004-03-23 Thread Eugene Ivanov
Ron, Thanks for your helpful responce. Concerning the stroke, this is what I foind myself through experimentation - the type of stroke that makes a sting vibrating up and down sonds much better for both high and low courses, so this stroke has been is the main focus in my the technique

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Arto Wikla
On Tue, 23 Mar 2004, Roman Turovsky wrote: IMO: Baroque Lute is ill-suited to any group endeavor, excepted accompanying a single voice singing maximum at mezza voce. You're playing continuo whether you're accompanying 1 voice or 100. Unless you are playing independent obbligato, which

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Arto Wikla
On Tue, 23 Mar 2004, Roman Turovsky wrote: Dear Roman, do you yourself REALLY PLAY the continuo? Repeatedly during February and March, and March 19 in public. So, a couple of months? And also once(!) in public? Or are you just speculating with the unknown? This just came to mind while

Re: Thoroughbass Playing ...

2004-03-23 Thread Arto Wikla
On Tue, 23 Mar 2004, Roman Turovsky wrote: do you yourself REALLY PLAY the continuo? Repeatedly during February and March, and March 19 in public. So, a couple of months? And also once(!) in public? And how long have you been playing Baroque Lute? A couple of years at the end of

early country music

2004-03-23 Thread bill
thank you for the input - what was sent was really useful. my interest in early country music stems from something i once read about how music which evolved in the cities during the renaissance totally eclipsed the interest that was formerly paid to music from the country - cantigas de santa

Re: HIP country music

2004-03-23 Thread Jon Murphy
Bill, If I may add to this, not all country music is from the same country. And the Spanish soldiers never quite made to Ireland and Scotland. I got that book (thank you those on the lute net that helped me with sources) on the Irish and Highland Harp. (It is unavailble, but I got it on a

Re: Beg. question, voicing 4-note chords.

2004-03-23 Thread Jon Murphy
Herbert, You and I seem to have a different problem, and as you know I started by just reading the music in McFarlane's Scots Lute. I am about to take my second lesson (the first was a couple of months ago, and I was instructed to stay away from songs and just practice (p,i) with thumb under type