[PEN-L:2296] Re: Re: Judith Butler, etc.3.0.1.32.19990119091110.00c50e60@popserver.panix.com 3.0.1.32.19990119100409.00a751ec@popserver.panix.com

1999-01-20 Thread rcam
the bit in italics was actually an excerpt from an old post of louis' (not my comments), which struck me as quite different to the blanket claim he was making now that shiva was 'inimical' to marxism. if he can see his way to dialogue, discussion and debate with the politics that shiva presents,

[PEN-L:2307] Re: Re: Judith Butler, etc.3.0.1.32.19990119091110.00c50e60@popserver.panix.com3.0.1.32.19990119100409.00a751ec@popserver.panix.com 3.0.1.32.19990119104717.00bfab90@popserver.panix.com

1999-01-20 Thread rcam
Louis Proyect wrote: From what I can gather, Butler's work falls into a category that I find sterile, namely "theory". I react to discussions of "theory" the way my dad used to movies with subtitles. much of marx's work is 'theory', no? a debate over texts, in this instacne the texts of

[PEN-L:2332] Cicero Clinton

1999-01-20 Thread Rob Schaap
G'day Penners, Wow, you really got yourselves a veritable Cicero of a president there! The guy can talk the knickers off an alectorate at a hundred yards. Some strategic work in there to use the surplus (which may not be quite as permanent a feature as his noble plans might imply) to lock in

[PEN-L:2341] Re: Re: 1998 Bad Writing Contest winners

1999-01-20 Thread Josh Mason
Sounds to me like Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets, by a certain J. Bradford DeLong. Josh [EMAIL PROTECTED] 01/20 12:27 AM that sounds like Robert Barsky's style ???

[PEN-L:2343] Re: Re: Re: 1998 Bad Writing Contest winners

1999-01-20 Thread jf noonan
On Tue, 19 Jan 1999 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: that sounds like Robert Barsky's style ??? Who's Robert Barsky? The only one I know is an English Prof that wrote a bio of Chomsky. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321

[PEN-L:2344] BLS Daily Report

1999-01-20 Thread Richardson_D
This message is in MIME format. Since your mail reader does not understand this format, some or all of this message may not be legible. --_=_NextPart_000_01BE4486.E5492330 BLS DAILY REPORT, TUESDAY, JANUARY 19, 1999 __The price of goods imported into the United States dropped 0.7 percent

[PEN-L:2345] RE: Cicero Clinton

1999-01-20 Thread Max Sawicky
. . . very carefully. Nothing about domestic debt, current account deficits, fiscal inflexibility . . . The apparent budget surpluses certainly reflect some fiscal flexibility. It's only the political rules and shibboleths that instill inflexibility. . . . Rather ambiguous on the degree

[PEN-L:2348] Re: Re: Fwd: Re: Fwd: Re: Re: Junk Science

1999-01-20 Thread Seth Sandronsky
Ken, "Libertarian" is now linked to the right-wing in much the same way "radical" is used to describe right-wingers at the Cato Institute. Seth Sandronsky Date: Mon, 18 Jan 1999 13:19:02 -0600 From: Ken Hanly [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject:

[PEN-L:2352] Re: Harvard Who?boundary=------------6FE059C6C4B9E7B730AC670A

1999-01-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
--6FE059C6C4B9E7B730AC670A Tom: I do not disagree. That is why I refer to "some quarters" of American labor. Henry Tom Lehman wrote: Dear Pen-L, Henry, most of the better and smarter American unions have positions on fair trade similar to ours. The smarter people in

[PEN-L:2354] Re: Judith Butler, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread Rosser Jr, John Barkley
Jerry, But, gee, Louis has confessed to all of us his bad behavior. We now know that he was drunk at the LM conference, by his own admission, and that he skipped crucial sessions because he was in his room reading, by his own admission. So, we can all see what his behavior was and

[PEN-L:2355] Trade unionism drives people to drink

1999-01-20 Thread Tom Walker
Lest one become intoxicated with mirth imbibing from Earl Grey's archaic turn-of-the-century fountain of illogic, I append to this excerpt from The Times, a series of refrains of the same old, same old tune from the Economist magazine as we approach the twilight of the same century. The Times

[PEN-L:2356] Re: Re: Judith Butler, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread James Michael Craven
Comment: Not as an "excuse" but if that empty pretentious rhetoric and totured syntax given in the example from Butler that won the Doublespeak/Gobbledegook Prize is an example of her normal prose and speech, I would need at least six Captain Morgan spiced Rums to go to hear her and six more

[PEN-L:2359] Re: Re: Re: Alan Sokal

1999-01-20 Thread Jim Devine
At 01:04 AM 1/20/99 -0600, Ken wrote: It is a long time I have read about Lysenko but what is said in the review sounds partly right. He was not a fraud but a good practical biologist. Nevertheless the rejection of Mendel's work was surely wrong and some of the propoganda e.g. citing against

[PEN-L:2363] Re: Re: Marx not a Marxist

1999-01-20 Thread Michael Hoover
Hal Draper's massive KARL MARX'S THEORY OF REVOLUTION has a discussion of the "I am not a Marxist" quote in one of its appendices. (sorry for such a sketchy reference, but the volumes are at home.) Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] above appears in foreword to vol. 2 (*The Politics of Social

[PEN-L:2365] Re: Judith Butler, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread Louis Proyect
This final paragraph in my last post was garbled. Here is a cleaned up version: I will scan in the whole article this evening and post it to PEN-L. It is very good. Levenson discusses Butler's "Excitable Speech" at length, which is a postmodernist attack on bans on "hate speech." Although the

[PEN-L:2367] euro-query

1999-01-20 Thread Jim Devine
I'm wondering what happens if one of the countries that makes up "Euroland" starts misbehaving (according to the established rules). Suppose that Holland (for example), is run by a government that borrows a lot to finance big cheese parties. I understand that there's a penalty (imposed by the

[PEN-L:2370] Jubilee 2000 enquiry (fwd)

1999-01-20 Thread michael
Forwarded message: Delivered-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Thu, 21 Jan 1999 11:03:38 +1100 Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sender: [EMAIL PROTECTED] From: "Sean Turnell" [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: POST-KEYNESIAN THOUGHT [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Jubilee 2000 enquiry Does anyone know of any economist who

[PEN-L:2374] Fwd: Frog -- or,fractured fairy talesboundary=part0_916888181_boundary

1999-01-20 Thread EST
This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --part0_916888181_boundary Once upon a time, in a land far away, a beautiful, independent, self assured princess happened upon a frog as she sat, contemplating ecological issues on the shores of an unpolluted pond in a verdant meadow near her

[PEN-L:2377] Re: Fwd: Frog -- or,fractured fairy tales

1999-01-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
A frog story in the era of falling oil prices A female accountant walks down a downtown sidewalk in Houston with a client and came across a frog who pleaded that it was a Texas oil man before he was truned into a frog, and one kiss from a woman would turn him back into a Taxas oil man with 1,000

[PEN-L:2378] Canada: Robert S. Kenny Prize in Marxist and Labour/Left Studies

1999-01-20 Thread Paul Zarembka
This is a MIME encapsulated message. --===_36A6927F_== For those interested, attached is a notice of the Robert S. Kenny Prize in Marxist and Labour/Left Studies for Canadians and landed immigrants, or others studying Canadian issues. The deadline is June 29, 1999.

[PEN-L:2380] articles in RRPE

1999-01-20 Thread Michael Yates
Friends, In the Fall 1998 issue of the Review of Radical Political Economics, there are articles by Max Sawicky on populism and by Louis Proyect on David Harvey and the American Indian. congratulations! Check them out. michael yates

[PEN-L:2379] Re: Re: Re: Re: Judith Butler, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread James Michael Craven
On 20 Jan 99 at 19:30, Dennis R Redmond wrote: On Wed, 20 Jan 1999, James Michael Craven wrote: I wonder how many working class women or women on Reservations could relate to or understand the rhetoric in the example of Butler's writings given in the Doublespeak award? I suspect few

[PEN-L:2375] Re: Re: Re: Judith Butler, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread Dennis R Redmond
On Wed, 20 Jan 1999, James Michael Craven wrote: I wonder how many working class women or women on Reservations could relate to or understand the rhetoric in the example of Butler's writings given in the Doublespeak award? I suspect few if any. So what? Are all those scientists who use

[PEN-L:2373] Re: RE: Cicero Clinton

1999-01-20 Thread MScoleman
In a message dated 99-01-20 10:19:31 EST, max says, amongst many other things, about the transfer of funds from social security to the stock market: This transfer is pretty comical. It goes like this: {and Max describes an unnecessarily complicated transfer process} I think the transfer

[PEN-L:2372] Re: Cicero Clinton

1999-01-20 Thread MScoleman
The problem with knocking Clinton is that -- as sleazy as the man is -- he still looks good next to the Republicans. Good and bad are relative terms and by comparison, slick willy is coming up smelling like a rose. Now, if he can just keep it in his pants for the duration What's really the

[PEN-L:2371] Re: Jubilee 2000 enquiry (fwd)

1999-01-20 Thread Robert Naiman
This is from the J2000 web page: http://www.oneworld.org/jubilee2000/index.html, which is searchable. It has some invocations of authority which might be useful. See esp. the reference to Kunibert Raffer of the University of Vienna. -bob naiman --- An International Bankruptcy

[PEN-L:2369] Article on Butler

1999-01-20 Thread Louis Proyect
THE PERFORMANCES OF JUDITH BUTLER BY MICHAEL LEVENSON September 1998, Lingua Franca JUDITH BUTLER IS SO IMPORTANT THAT the worst thing to do when discussing her work would be to nod and praise She is a supreme late-millennial theorist, trying to shift the weight of a heavy legacy while still

[PEN-L:2364] Re: Judith Butler, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread Louis Proyect
From "The Performances of Judith Butler" by Michael Levenson in the Sept. "Lingua Franca": --- This is the very terrible claustrophobia of her vision, constructed brick by heavy brick from the theorists she cobbles together. Everything is packed up, hemmed in, wadded tightly together in a single

[PEN-L:2362] Long-Awaited Baby Boomer Die-Off To Begin Soon, Experts Say

1999-01-20 Thread Tom Lehman
This is a multi-part message in MIME format. http://www.theonion.com/onion3502/boomer_dieoff.html name="boomer_dieoff.html" filename="boomer_dieoff.html" er_dieoff.html" er_dieoff.html" HTML HEAD TITLELong-Awaited Baby Boomer Die-Off To Begin Soon, Experts Say /TITLE

[PEN-L:2361] Re: Re: Re: Alan Sokal

1999-01-20 Thread Rosser Jr, John Barkley
This is accurate as far as it goes, but there are some weird twists in addition. In particular, the ultimate fan of Lysenko was Khrushchev and it was during his rule that Lysenko's power reached its peak, although it did not coincide then with deadly purges of his opponents as it did

[PEN-L:2360] IMF repentant!?!

1999-01-20 Thread Jim Devine
from SLATE magazine: The LA Times fronts the International Monetary Fund's publication of a report stating that the agency "badly misgauged" the Asian financial meltdown. The story is carried inside everywhere else. The report admits that the IMF was slow to see the extent of the banking overhaul

[PEN-L:2358] Re: Marx not a Marxist

1999-01-20 Thread Jim Devine
At 05:48 PM 1/19/99 -0800, Tom wrote: Michael Perelman mentioned that Marx's statement that he was not a "Marxist" was by way of disassociating himself with a pamphlet about laziness written by his son-in-law. That presumably would be "The Right to be Lazy" by Paul Lafargue. Reportedly, Lafargue

[PEN-L:2357] Re: RE: Cicero Clinton

1999-01-20 Thread Brad De Long
. . . very carefully. Nothing about domestic debt, current account deficits, fiscal inflexibility . . . The apparent budget surpluses certainly reflect some fiscal flexibility. It's only the political rules and shibboleths that instill inflexibility. . . . Rather ambiguous on the degree

[PEN-L:2353] THE CRISIS IN BRITISH INDUSTRY

1999-01-20 Thread Tom Walker
Below is an excerpt from the first installment of Pratt's 1901 series in the London Times. It sets the keynote for the entire discussion. In a way, it is "old hat" rehearsing employer complaints that no doubt go back before the building of the pyramids. But the finesse with which Pratt deploys

[PEN-L:2351] Re: Re: Re: Fwd: Re: Fwd: Re: Re: Junk Science

1999-01-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
The old left, feeling threatened by the new left, joins the old right to form a new center. The new right, disillusioned by the progressive new center, joins the new left in a transitional battle against the new center, while reserving its best strength for the pending struggle against the new

[PEN-L:2350] Re: Re: Re: 1998 Bad Writing Contest winners

1999-01-20 Thread michael
Sorry, I thought it was the Barsky/DeLong article. I was wrong. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

[PEN-L:2349] Harvard Who?boundary=------------EBA28E4CCEB953461B60E60C

1999-01-20 Thread Tom Lehman
This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --EBA28E4CCEB953461B60E60C Dear Pen-L, Henry, most of the better and smarter American unions have positions on fair trade similar to ours. The smarter people in China must also realize the need for free and independent labor

[PEN-L:2347] Re: Harvard

1999-01-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
My remarks on the Harvard Trade Union Program is conditioned by incessant criticism from some quarters in American labor on China's policy on unionism. The following has been posted by me on another list in response to that criticism. It may be pertinent to this discussion. In politics, context

[PEN-L:2346] Re: Harvard

1999-01-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
I do not need to apologize for my posts on the Harvard Trade Union Program since my remarks are not attacks, but merely observations of the institutional contradictions of the arrangement. No remarks were made by me on the people involved in the program. It would be more progress, however, if the

[PEN-L:2342] Harvard

1999-01-20 Thread Ellen T. Frank
I apologize for any criticism of Elaine Barnard and the Harvard Trade Union Program that some may have inferred from my earlier post (meant humorously!). Elaine Barnard is a terrific person, a wonderful speaker and superb organizer. My comment about

[PEN-L:2340] Re: Judith Butler, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread Gerald Levy
Reply to Michael P: a) I did not re-raise this issue. Proyect did when he revealed his drunken behavior, etc. at the "Rethinking Marxism" conference. Blame him. b) There was nothing in my post that could fit any reasonable definition of a flame. c) The *reason* this issue won't go away is

[PEN-L:2339] Re: Re: Alan Sokalv04011706b2c90eb442c1@[166.84.250.86]199901181421.JAA03064@merhaba.cc.columbia.edu199901180736.BAA05096@echo.flash.net

1999-01-20 Thread Ken Hanly
It sounds quite interesting I'll have to see if I can get the book. No doubt given my local universities' library I'll be calling on interlibrary loan. It is a long time I have read about Lysenko but what is said in the review sounds partly right. He was not a fraud but a good practical

[PEN-L:2294] Re: Re: Re: Judith Butler, etc.

1999-01-20 Thread rcam
louis is 'extremely familiar' with shiva, so he will know that shiva is not a postmodernist, nor a poststructuralist, but third-worldist eco-feminist. Louis Proyect wrote: I am extremely familiar with Vandana Shiva's ideas and regard them as inimical to everything that Marx stood for. and,