Re: [R-sig-phylo] model averaging for discrete character evolution

2019-08-07 Thread Liam Revell
Hi Jake. [Edit: I see just now that Brian has also responded to this inquiry. I have no doubt that his message is more insightful than mine - but I'll nonetheless send what I was writing anyway just in case it contributes anything useful to the discussion.] If you're simply interested in the

[R-sig-phylo] model averaging for discrete character evolution

2019-08-07 Thread Jacob Berv
Dear R-sig phylo I’ve been running a few discrete character Mk type models using phytool's SIMMAP — and I had the idea that it might be useful to try model averaging across posterior probabilities for node states. Might this make sense to do, to avoid problems associated with model ranking

Re: [R-sig-phylo] model averaging for discrete character evolution

2019-08-07 Thread Brian O'Meara
I think this is ok in theory: say you have 10% of the weight on the ER model, 90% on the ARD model, so your states at the nodes are based 10% on the probabilities from ER, 90% from ARD. [Worth noting, of course, that with N tips with one character each, estimating N-1 ancestral states, plus the