On Wed, Mar 05, 2014 at 10:53:09PM -0800, Clifford Snow wrote:
Why do I see so many new mappers make edits without a commit comment? Is it
because iD doesn't prompt for a commit message? iD issue 1488 is open but
not acted upon. I wonder why. Is it because the developers don't think
commit
Hi,
Richard Z. schrieb:
another problem that makes the history (from the map page) almost useless
is that about 2/3 of all changesets indicate a very large change area box.
Seems like most wheelmap.org edits change the whole planet at once.
Somehow the locality of changesets should be
IMHO commit comments are very useful if done right.
Some comments are as useless as no comment (e.g. changes, more
changes and so on), but asking/reminding/triggering users to give a
comment at least increases the ratio of given comments; and hopefully
that could increas the ratio of useful
On 06/03/14 06:53, Clifford Snow wrote:
Why do I see so many new mappers make edits without a commit comment? Is
it because iD doesn't prompt for a commit message? iD issue 1488 is open
but not acted upon. I wonder why. Is it because the developers don't
think commit comments are needed?
Why
Hi,
On 03/06/2014 07:53 AM, Clifford Snow wrote:
Why do I see so many new mappers make edits without a commit comment? Is
it because iD doesn't prompt for a commit message?
Well it doesn't force you but the changeset comment field is well
visible IMHO.
I'm wondering what the community
On 06/03/2014, Tom Hughes t...@compton.nu wrote:
I think the answer to your question is simply that many people are too
lazy to enter one.
If comparing editors, there's also the fact that iD users tend to save
much more often than JOSM users, making smaller changesets. Give a
description of
Am 06/mar/2014 um 12:45 schrieb moltonel 3x Combo molto...@gmail.com:
If comparing editors, there's also the fact that iD users tend to save
much more often than JOSM users, making smaller changesets
last week there was a user on talk-it who lost 2 hours of work with ID because
of a
6h57
Objet : Re: [OSM-talk] No Changeset Comments from iD
Am 06/mar/2014 um 12:45 schrieb moltonel 3x Combo molto...@gmail.com:
If comparing editors, there's also the fact that iD users tend to save
much more often than JOSM users, making smaller changesets
last week there was a user
On 06/03/14 15:02, Richard Z. wrote:
would it be technically doable that the JOSM and ID would automatically generate
a short summary of the changes, something like 3 highway edited, 1 waterways
deleted, 50 tag only changes would become
3he,1000wd,50t
after which the user could provide a
Am 06/mar/2014 um 16:04 schrieb Tom Hughes t...@compton.nu:
For the love of god, no.
+1, the point of a changeset comment is to give information that is not
contained in the changes itself (eg about the why, like removed restaurant
because it is closed etc) while everything intrinsic is
Here, let's have some numbers. As of the last changeset dump (Feb. 28th)
iD:
total changesets: 1,744,610
changesets with a comment: 745,774
43% comment rate
Potlatch2:
total changesets: 3,594,415
changesets with comment: 1,971,298
54% comment rate
JOSM:
total changesets: 10,289,418
changesets
On 06/03/2014, Toby Murray toby.mur...@gmail.com wrote:
Here, let's have some numbers. As of the last changeset dump (Feb. 28th)
Interesting numbers, thanks.
What these numbers don't show is how many comments are useless repeated
fixed problems ones. JOSM auto-fills the comment with whatever
On Thu, Mar 6, 2014 at 4:51 PM, moltonel 3x Combo molto...@gmail.comwrote:
On 06/03/2014, Toby Murray toby.mur...@gmail.com wrote:
Here, let's have some numbers. As of the last changeset dump (Feb. 28th)
Interesting numbers, thanks.
What these numbers don't show is how many comments are
Toby, this is great data. Thanks.
On Thu, Mar 6, 2014 at 1:36 PM, Toby Murray toby.mur...@gmail.com wrote:
Here, let's have some numbers. As of the last changeset dump (Feb. 28th)
iD:
total changesets: 1,744,610
changesets with a comment: 745,774
43% comment rate
What got me first was the
Richard Z. writes:
would it be technically doable that the JOSM and ID would automatically generate
a short summary of the changes, something like 3 highway edited, 1 waterways
deleted, 50 tag only changes would become
3he,1000wd,50t
after which the user could provide a more generic
15 matches
Mail list logo
