Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-04 Thread Simon Ward
On Wed, Jul 01, 2009 at 08:25:54PM +0200, Thomas Schäfer wrote: Well we're largely dependent on UCL (and Bytemark to a lesser extent) being able to allocate us IPv6 addresses for our machines. Have you asked ? (this year, not in the Dark Ages) I don’t know about UCL (I imagine as a

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-04 Thread John Smith
--- On Sat, 4/7/09, Simon Ward si...@bleah.co.uk wrote: I don’t know about UCL (I imagine as a University they probably already have an easy route to IPv6), but Bytemark specifically offer it[1].  I guess that would cover the wiki and repository. Someone already commented that UCL has

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread SteveC
On 2 Jul 2009, at 08:57, Tom Hughes wrote: Thomas Schäfer wrote: sorry the theme is for the most of the people off topic. They use the application osm via internet. But the fundament of the internet (its protocol) is changing. We (the admins) are all well aware of this. I personally

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread Dave Stubbs
2009/7/3 SteveC st...@asklater.com: On 2 Jul 2009, at 08:57, Tom Hughes wrote: Thomas Schäfer wrote: sorry the theme is for the most of the people off topic. They use the application osm via internet. But the fundament of the internet (its protocol) is changing. We (the admins) are all

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread tschae...@t-online.de
Please, when will OSM support IP over pigeon? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IP_over_Avian_Carriers Best Steve You are not up2date: IPoSN is in http://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc5514.txt Therefore the solution must be: OSM over IPv6 over Social Networks But lets make the first

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread Stefan de Konink
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 SteveC wrote: On 2 Jul 2009, at 08:57, Tom Hughes wrote: Thomas Schäfer wrote: sorry the theme is for the most of the people off topic. They use the application osm via internet. But the fundament of the internet (its protocol) is

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread John Smith
--- On Fri, 3/7/09, Stefan de Konink ste...@konink.de wrote: then you win. If you want to win, all you have to do according to a previous poster is draw up a migration plan for OSM. If that's the case, I'm not sure where the hold up is exactly because the work the .nl guys have put in proves

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread Stefan de Konink
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 John Smith wrote: --- On Fri, 3/7/09, Stefan de Konink ste...@konink.de wrote: then you win. If you want to win, all you have to do according to a previous poster is draw up a migration plan for OSM. As mentioned in the serious post before.

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread Russ Nelson
On Jul 3, 2009, at 8:15 AM, John Smith wrote: I'm still scratching my head as to why this isn't possible to be honest. It's possible, but it's pointless. First, there is no IPv4 to IPv6 transition plan. The two protocols don't coexist. Second, unless you have an IPv4 address, you

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread marcus.wolschon
On 3 Jul 2009 08:47:04 -0400, Russ Nelson r...@cloudmade.com wrote: On Jul 3, 2009, at 8:15 AM, John Smith wrote: I'm still scratching my head as to why this isn't possible to be honest. It's possible, but it's pointless. First, there is no IPv4 to IPv6 transition plan. The two

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread Jonathan Bennett
John Smith wrote: I'm still scratching my head as to why this isn't possible to be honest. It's possible, but it appears the people who think it's so important just want to sit on their arses and have someone else do the work. By comparison, when Relations were proposed, they happened because

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread Stefan de Konink
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Jonathan Bennett wrote: John Smith wrote: I'm still scratching my head as to why this isn't possible to be honest. It's possible, but it appears the people who think it's so important just want to sit on their arses and have someone else do

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread John Smith
--- On Fri, 3/7/09, Jonathan Bennett openstreet...@jonno.cix.co.uk wrote: It's possible, but it appears the people who think it's so important just want to sit on their arses and have someone else do the work. To be fair, only those with root access to production systems and contacts with

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread Aun Yngve Johnsen
On 03/07/2009, at 05:38, SteveC wrote: On 2 Jul 2009, at 08:57, Tom Hughes wrote: Thomas Schäfer wrote: sorry the theme is for the most of the people off topic. They use the application osm via internet. But the fundament of the internet (its protocol) is changing. We (the admins)

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread Stefan de Konink
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Aun Yngve Johnsen wrote: An implementation of the protocol for both the wiki and OSM in general would mean that OSM coverage will be virtually global, and no longer depending on broadband connections. I wonder what the RTT would be from

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread John Smith
--- On Fri, 3/7/09, Stefan de Konink ste...@konink.de wrote: I wonder what the RTT would be from UK to USA. Maybe even the amount of packetloss; I mean if OpenShortestPigeonFlight is not used... that could be enormous. Assuming there is no large amount of packet losses due to packet

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-03 Thread OJ W
wasn't OSM's preferred link-layer discussed elsewhere? http://fakestevec.blogspot.com/2009/04/new-ceo-appointed.html On Fri, Jul 3, 2009 at 4:10 PM, John Smithdelta_foxt...@yahoo.com wrote: --- On Fri, 3/7/09, Stefan de Konink ste...@konink.de wrote: I wonder what the RTT would be from UK

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Donnerstag 02 Juli 2009 schrieb Marcus Wolschon: Guys... what could it hurt to set up an ipv6.openstreetmap.org with only an -record or with and A -records pointing at the 6to4 -address associated with the current IPv4-addresse(s) to let users and admins experiment without causing

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, Thomas Schäfer wrote: This is a bad idea. Do it right or do it not. ... has never been OSM's attitude so far, so why change now. Honestly, I get the feeling you're on a personal crusade here for doing things right which is of no relevance to most of us. You might as well tell us that we

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Donnerstag 02 Juli 2009 schrieb Frederik Ramm: Hi, Claudius wrote: There are not enough IPv4 adresses for Africa and Latin America already which is why they are assigning IPv6 only already. Now with the new east african internet cable this might lead to even more IPv6 users in

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread John Smith
--- On Thu, 2/7/09, Frederik Ramm frede...@remote.org wrote: This is a bad idea. Do it right or do it not. ... has never been OSM's attitude so far, so why change now. Honestly, I Judging by my experience, there will be most likely be between 0.01% and 1% IPv6 traffic v IPv4 traffic,

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Frederik Ramm schrieb am Donnerstag 02 Juli 2009: Hi, Thomas Schäfer wrote: This is a bad idea. Do it right or do it not. ... has never been OSM's attitude so far, so why change now. Honestly, I get the feeling you're on a personal crusade here for doing things right which is of no

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Donnerstag 02 Juli 2009 schrieb John Smith: get the feeling you're on a personal crusade here for It sucks when people turn things into a religious issue and go off on their high horses how everything should be done perfectly. Your horse isn't high? Thomas

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread John Smith
--- On Thu, 2/7/09, Thomas Schäfer tschae...@t-online.de wrote: Your horse isn't high? I prefer soap boxes personally, they don't tend to shy ;) ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Ken Guest
On Thu, Jul 2, 2009 at 9:17 AM, John Smith delta_foxt...@yahoo.com wrote: --- On Thu, 2/7/09, Thomas Schäfer tschae...@t-online.de wrote: Your horse isn't high? I prefer soap boxes personally, they don't tend to shy ;) or kick... :( k. -- http://short.ie/osminguardian

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Donnerstag 02 Juli 2009 schrieb Tom Hughes: We (the admins) are all well aware of this. I personally have had IPv6 on my home network for some years now. That is nice. There are reasons why this is not as simple as it sounds. I know that sounds a bit cryptic but please believe me when I

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Dirk-Lüder Kreie
Thomas Schäfer schrieb: It is probably a moot point anyway because, as someone else pointed out, either UCL does it or they don't and we would be the last ones to raise a fuss with them over anything. You don't want realize. I have to accept that. Sorry. OSM is largely a meritocracy

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-02 Thread Stefan de Konink
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Dirk-Lüder Kreie wrote: Thomas Schäfer schrieb: It is probably a moot point anyway because, as someone else pointed out, either UCL does it or they don't and we would be the last ones to raise a fuss with them over anything. You don't want

[OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Hello, sorry the theme is for the most of the people off topic. They use the application osm via internet. But the fundament of the internet (its protocol) is changing. Therefore my appeal: Ask your next admin/provider for ipv6 , make a plan and make the network working, add the to dns

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Sander Hoentjen
On Wed, 2009-07-01 at 16:43 +0200, Thomas Schäfer wrote: Hello, sorry the theme is for the most of the people off topic. They use the application osm via internet. But the fundament of the internet (its protocol) is changing. Therefore my appeal: Ask your next admin/provider for ipv6

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Jonathan Bennett
Thomas Schäfer wrote: Therefore my appeal: Ask your next admin/provider for ipv6 , make a plan and make the network working, add the to dns an be happy. Solve the little problems . Asked and answered. http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk/2007-October/018603.html -- Jonathan

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Jonathan Bennett schrieb am Mittwoch 01 Juli 2009: Asked and answered. No, the answer was not satisfying. http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk/2007-October/018603.html Now we have 2009! Regards, Thomas Schäfer ___ talk mailing list

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Jonathan Bennett
Thomas Schäfer wrote: No, the answer was not satisfying. What part of it's not under our control didn't you understand? -- Jonathan (Jonobennett) ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread John Smith
--- On Wed, 1/7/09, Jonathan Bennett openstreet...@jonno.cix.co.uk wrote: What part of it's not under our control didn't you understand? Have you asked your provider lately about IPv6 address space? Most providers seem to be setting up IPv6 silently and/or more proactive lately when it comes

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Stefan de Konink
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Jonathan Bennett wrote: Thomas Schäfer wrote: No, the answer was not satisfying. What part of it's not under our control didn't you understand? Set up a SixXS tunnel and have fun :) Stefan -BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE- Version: GnuPG

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Ondrej Novy
hi, On Wed, Jul 01, 2009 at 04:20:55PM +, John Smith wrote: Have you asked your provider lately about IPv6 address space? Most providers seem to be setting up IPv6 silently and/or more proactive lately when it comes to IPv6. this is true, completly silent most of them :).

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Mittwoch 01 Juli 2009 schrieb OJ W: Improving the net in other directions, can the OSM servers be made contactable via the I2P network? This is a totaly different problem. Regards, Thomas ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Jonathan Bennett schrieb am Mittwoch 01 Juli 2009: Thomas Schäfer wrote: No, the answer was not satisfying. What part of it's not under our control didn't you understand? Do you mean this part of the answer from 2007: Well we're largely dependent on UCL (and Bytemark to a lesser extent)

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Stefan de Konink schrieb am Mittwoch 01 Juli 2009: - gpg control packet Jonathan Bennett wrote: Thomas Schäfer wrote: No, the answer was not satisfying. What part of it's not under our control didn't you understand? Set up a SixXS tunnel and have fun :) I have fun. I use tunnels

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Mittwoch 01 Juli 2009 schrieb Sander Hoentjen: Heh well if you insist on viewing osm over ipv6 you can always visit the netherlands: tile.openstreetmap.nl is an alias for productie.openstreetmap.nl. productie.openstreetmap.nl has address 93.186.179.161 productie.openstreetmap.nl has IPv6

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Russ Nelson
On Jul 1, 2009, at 2:47 PM, Thomas Schäfer wrote: Maybe we should move the OSM-servers to the netherlands, because the UK is not able to serve the world. I appreciate your enthusiasm for IPv6, Thomas, but this topic is essentially completely unrelated to OpenStreetMap. When the time

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Mittwoch 01 Juli 2009 schrieb Russ Nelson: On Jul 1, 2009, at 2:47 PM, Thomas Schäfer wrote: Maybe we should move the OSM-servers to the netherlands, because the UK is not able to serve the world. I appreciate your enthusiasm for IPv6, Thomas, but this topic is essentially completely

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Jonathan Bennett
Stefan de Konink wrote: Set up a SixXS tunnel and have fun :) Great idea! How long do you think it will take you? ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Jonathan Bennett
Thomas Schäfer wrote: Lets solving the Chicken-and-egg problem in ipv6 by simply doing it. OK -- when are you available to set it up? ___ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, Thomas Schäfer wrote: Discussions about Ipv6 is not wasted hot air. It is related to osm, because osm should be based on it, but isn't. It shoud simply be done, then is no further discussion about it. Let's be pragmatic here like we usually are. If we were to switch to IPv6 today

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Stefan de Konink
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Jonathan Bennett wrote: Stefan de Konink wrote: Set up a SixXS tunnel and have fun :) Great idea! How long do you think it will take you? For me probably about an hour if Jeroen is online ;) Stefan -BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE- Version:

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Stefan de Konink
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 Frederik Ramm wrote: Thomas Schäfer wrote: Discussions about Ipv6 is not wasted hot air. It is related to osm, because osm should be based on it, but isn't. It shoud simply be done, then is no further discussion about it. Let's be pragmatic

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Mittwoch 01 Juli 2009 schrieb Frederik Ramm: Hi, Thomas Schäfer wrote: Discussions about Ipv6 is not wasted hot air. It is related to osm, because osm should be based on it, but isn't. It shoud simply be done, then is no further discussion about it. Let's be pragmatic here like we

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Thomas Schäfer
Am Mittwoch 01 Juli 2009 schrieb Jonathan Bennett: Thomas Schäfer wrote: Lets solving the Chicken-and-egg problem in ipv6 by simply doing it. OK -- when are you available to set it up? To enable radvd at the router? To add some /PTR-Records at the DNS? To check the firewall and to

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Claudius
Am 01.07.2009 22:12, Frederik Ramm: Hi, Thomas Schäfer wrote: Discussions about Ipv6 is not wasted hot air. It is related to osm, because osm should be based on it, but isn't. It shoud simply be done, then is no further discussion about it. Let's be pragmatic here like we usually are. If

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Steven Le Roux
On Wed, Jul 1, 2009 at 9:01 PM, Russ Nelson r...@cloudmade.com wrote: On Jul 1, 2009, at 2:47 PM, Thomas Schäfer wrote: Maybe we should move the OSM-servers to the netherlands, because the UK is not able to serve the world. I appreciate your enthusiasm for IPv6, Thomas, but this topic

Re: [OSM-talk] AAAA openstreetmap still doesn't use ipv6

2009-07-01 Thread Marcus Wolschon
Guys... what could it hurt to set up an ipv6.openstreetmap.org with only an -record or with and A -records pointing at the 6to4 -address associated with the current IPv4-addresse(s) to let users and admins experiment without causing any issues with the openstreetmap.org -name? It is