On Mon, 28 Jun 2004, J. Andrew Rogers wrote:


There is most certainly not an infinite range of solutions, and there is an extremely narrow range of economically viable solutions.

There are certainly an infinite range of solutions in AI, even for a specific problem, let alone for a space of many problems. What's an optimal economic solution for application X is a waste of resources for application Y.


I think the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate how this range is extremely narrow. Even within this mailing list there are vastly divergent opinions on the basic fundamentals of the architechture that might do the job. We can't even settle the simple question of whether it's better pursuing biological analogues or starting from scratch.



I would state that your entire characterization of technological history is incorrect. There is very little diversity in engineering in practice, and I don't expect AGI to be any different. Most of the variation between implementations of a given core technology is window dressing or attributable to variations in specification.

We're perched on the edge of a semantic debate concerning what's fundamentally different.


But I'll content myself with the concrete example of PC CPU's

They do the same job, but they work differently inside, different people have designed them and most importantly for the purposes of this discussion: different companies get money when I purchase them.

And the only reason CPU's function similarly is because they need to run the same software at an instruction level. AGI will be under no such constraint.




You can parameterize an implementation for variation, but you can't parameterize the underlying mathematics and physics that allows a technology to exist in the first place. AGI is a math problem with huge

Except that this isn't about physics, it's about information processing. And given a certain amount of information processing resources (as limited by physics yes), there are a great many ways to use them to perform a task.



economic consequences.  Economics will dictate the implementation
parameters of the mathematics, and will strongly bound the architecture
of successful implementations.  There won't be diversity, there will be
slightly different flavors of the same solution.

Only in the very first iteration. The solution space we explore will bifurcate rapidly.



Any design competition will be decisive and short-lived. There will be no second place. You are mis-modeling how AGI technology will interact with the marketplace by treating it as a conventional production-bound widget when this will be a case of something very different. There is only one barrier to entry into the AGI market, but that barrier is precisely such that the first-mover will have a decisive advantage.

AI will be bound by the same economic models as everything else, but you
have to use valid data and parameters or you'll end up with completely
broken expectations.  AI technology is almost ideally pathological from
a market competition perspective.


It's true, I'm fitting AGI into the conventional mold of product development and economics.


I do this because I think AGI development is going to be an iterative process with solutions that are incremental improvements, and with several companies close on each other's heels. There won't be a clear winner, because the fitness landscape of AGI is poorly defined.



I'd like to hear how you define AI being pathological from a market competition perspective? Is it because AI's will improve themselvers, and therefore the early winners will accelerate their own development process?

-------
To unsubscribe, change your address, or temporarily deactivate your subscription, please go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to