Yep. Whether or not I effectively am the recordkeeper doesn't matter. What matters is that I'm *required* to or not.
Required to be a recordkeeper = / = Am a recordkeeper. I could do absolutely no recordkeeping and the thing still holds (if it even happens, because ossification might stop it from existing at all), because I'm still *required* to recordkeep, regardless of if I actually can do it or not. On Thu, Oct 4, 2018 at 5:31 PM [email protected] < [email protected]> wrote: > On Thu, 2018-10-04 at 10:11 -0400, D Margaux wrote: > > Nevertheless, Agora is a nomic of laws, not players. If your pledge > > is valid, and if it imposed on you a duty to be recordkeepor of > > everything, then I believe it is more likely than not that all > > actions in the universe would become regulated actions under R2125. > > That would render it IMPOSSIBLE to perform many previously > > unregulated actions—such as breathing or eating—that are not > > expressly authorized by the Rules. It follows that, if your pledge > > were valid, Agora would be ossified and itself rendered > > IMPOSSIBLE. As a result, I deem it more likely than not that your > > attempted pledge was INEFFECTIVE. > > Is it possible that the pledge requires Cuddlebeam to be the > recordkeepor of everything, without actually /making/ Cuddlebeam the > recordkeepor of everything? Compare the hypothetical pledge "I pledge > to be the Speaker", made by someone who isn't the Speaker, or the > hypothetical pledge "I pledge that 2 + 2 is 5". > > -- > ais523 > >
