Thanks Steve and Javi, Questions inline below
On 2020-03-25 3:32 p.m., Javier Hernandez wrote: > Steve's right, > > you can remove all of them, the web solutions were used during > Cloud4all, so there's no reason to keep them there. > Regarding manuel, vladimir and chromeDefault, I don't think they're > still being used for demos and if they are, they shouldn't be used. > Manuel and Vladimir were created to demo the different matchmakers > (not supported anymore) and prefs changes upon environmental context > changes (not supported anymore) during the last cloud4all review. > chromeDefault is a preference set that has settings for the old chrome > extension created during cloud4all, so it can be axed without any problem. I was proposing deleting the use of the web solutions from these preferences sets. You are suggesting going further and deleting the preferences sets entirely -- that we will no longer have snapsets "manuel", "vladimir", nor "chromeDefault". Okay with me. > > If some nostalgic people want the adaptations that they get when > keying-in as vladimir or manuel, we can create new ones or even update > them to remove anything that doesn't make sense to be there. Bern? Gregg? > > Thanks for asking Joseph. > Cheers, > Javi > > > On Wed, Mar 25, 2020 at 8:14 PM Steven Githens <[email protected] > <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: > > Hi Joseph, > > I’m pretty sure all the solutions in your list haven’t been active > or used since Cloud4All, and I think removing them wouldn’t break > anybody’s stuff, unless it were another scenario like we saw > before where one of the prefSets was actively being used for a > health check or performance test. I think we might want to > carefully review manuel.json5, vladimir.json5, and > chromeDefault.json5 since they are toplevel friendly to pronounce > names without underscores that may have been used for demo’ing. I > feel like the the rest probably aren’t referenced anywhere. > What do you mean by "the rest"? The rest of the web solutions? The rest of the preferences sets I listed that reference those solutions? Or both? (Aside: I wonder if we can delete the preferences sets I listed that are used in the tests -- the ones in "universal/tests/data/preferences/". It's likely tests will be affected, but maybe those tests can be deleted as well. I'll investigate.) Thanks again. > > -Steve > > > On Mar 25, 2020, at 7:05 AM, Joseph Scheuhammer > <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: > > > > Hi all, > > > > I'm working on GPII-4400: Remove/retire the 'web' solutions > registry and > > related material [1] > > > > I've found that some of these solutions appear in some of the > > preferences. And, a subset of those are the basis for snapsets > that are > > loaded into the database by the dataloader. > > > > A simple way forward is to remove any use of 'web' solutions > within the > > preferences. But, I don't actually know what these solutions > are or if > > anyone or anything in the system really depends on them. If you > have > > information or insights, let me know. > > > > The 'web' solutions registry is located in > > gpii-universal/testData/solutions/web.json5. The solutions > listed there > > are: > > > > - org.chrome.cloud4chrome (Cloud4Chrome) > > - org.mozilla.cloud4firefox (Cloud4Firefox) > > - com.bdigital.easit4all (Easit4all) > > - info.cloud4all.JME (JME Cloud4all Themes) > > - net.gpii.smarthouses (smarthouse) > > - es.codefactory.android.app.ma > <http://es.codefactory.android.app.ma> (Mobile Accessibility) > > - de.fraunhofer.iao.C4A-TVM (C4A-TVM) > > - eu.gpii.olb (Online Banking Demonstrator) > > > > The affected snapset preferences are found in > > "gpii-universal/testData/preferences/". Some of the affected > > preferences are not snapsets but are used for testing and are > found in > > "gpii-universal/tests/data/preferences/". Here is a list of the > > preferences files that reference at a web solution, and the > solution it > > references. I've noted the preferences that are used as snapsets. > > > > - org.chrome.cloud4chrome > > - gpii-universal/testData/preferences/chromeDefault.json5 > (snapset) > > - gpii-universal/testData/preferences/manuel.json5 (snapset) > > - gpii-universal/testData/preferences/vladimir.json5 (snapset) > > - gpii-universal/tests/data/preferences/chrome2.json5 > > - gpii-universal/tests/data/preferences/chrome_and_firefox.json5 > > > > - org.mozilla.cloud4firefox > > - gpii-universal/tests/data/preferences/chrome_and_firefox.json5 > > - gpii-universal/tests/data/preferences/firefox.json5 > > > > - com.bdigital.easit4all > > - doesn't appear in a preferences set > > > > - info.cloud4all.JME > > - gpii-universal/testData/preferences/jme_app.json5 (snapset) > > > > - net.gpii.smarthouses > > - doesn't appear in a preferences set > > > > - es.codefactory.android.app.ma > <http://es.codefactory.android.app.ma> > > - doesn't appear in a preferences set > > > > - de.fraunhofer.iao.C4A-TVM > > - gpii-universal/testData/preferences/tvm_jasmin.json5 (snapset) > > - gpii-universal/testData/preferences/tvm_sammy.json5 (snapset) > > > > - eu.gpii.olb > > - gpii-universal/testData/preferences/olb_Alicia_app.json5 > (snapset) > > > > Thanks for any help. > > > > [1] https://issues.gpii.net/browse/GPII-4400 > > > > -- > > ;;;;joseph. > > > > 'The only reason for time is so that everything doesn't happen > all at once.' > > - B. Banzai - > > > > _______________________________________________ > > Architecture mailing list > > [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> > > https://lists.gpii.net/mailman/listinfo/architecture > > _______________________________________________ > Architecture mailing list > [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> > https://lists.gpii.net/mailman/listinfo/architecture > -- ;;;;joseph. 'The only reason for time is so that everything doesn't happen all at once.' - B. Banzai - _______________________________________________ Architecture mailing list [email protected] https://lists.gpii.net/mailman/listinfo/architecture
