what u guys trying to prove...If u call that copy, then IR and every other single MD's on earth has copied..all i can say is u guys are too PROUD of ur knowledge in music and try to comment professionally without respect to other musicians...If u are a musician i can say u cannot achieve in music if u go on thinking the same way...in that case in any filed u cannot see succes bacause u underestimate ones effort..BOSE no variety..thats not only one mans effort..so many musicians has put in thier heart and soul and u just listen it (on the net..i don't think u bought it) and come out with a very cheap comment...
--- In [email protected], Pavana Kumar CM <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Well Joel, I would like to add the following > > If you see even Bose, many people felt that it has > wide variety. But frankly I don't think so. If you > see songs Desh Ki Mitti, Ghoomparani, Ekla Chalo and > Azaadi all have the same skeleton tune it is just the > orchestration and other masala added to it which makes > it feel different. In fact if you carefully look at > the Chorus of the Azaadi song (also the whole song) it > is nothing but our National Anthem (Jana Gana > Mana....) repackaged as it is the different tune. > > Afghanisthan theme in Bose also looks very shabby to > me because in those times much better feel was given > in tamil movies like Guleba Kavali & Alibaba by MSV & > RM. See those movies to experience. In fact I won't > be surprised if he has used some of the notes just > like that. > > The Same is the case in other movies also > > Lagaan - Mitwa, Ore Chori... are both same skeleton > tunes > Swades - Sawariyan is IR's tune (also used by other > copy cat Nadeem Shravan in Raja Hindustani i.e Pardesi > Pardesi...) > Zubeidaa - Dheere Dheere..., Hain Na..., Door Kahi... > all have same skeleton tune > > I agree that music directors will use their popular > tunes in many movies, but I don't see people using > that in the same movie. This shows the creativity of > that person. > > As you say his music was once upon a time very > refreshing and a welcome change. I think this magic > started to weaken after Kandukonden Kandukonden. That > is the last album which had masterpieces with each > song having different shades and different feel like > > 1. Enna Solla - Most in raga Bhairavi > 2. Kanna Moochi - In Senchurutti > 3. Title Song - In Kadana Kutoohalam > 4. Enge Enadhu - In Ragamalika (Sindhu Bhairvai in > Starting) > 5. Konjum Mainakkale - In Madhyamavathi (although not > pure). > > See how wide variety these songs were. Now he is > becoming montonous and the variety is dying down. > > I hope in the future movies atlease he brings back his > old variety > > Rgds, > Pavana Kumar C.M > > > > --- Joel <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Did anybody know that ARR is a copycat tooo....well > > ? > > But unlike HJ or other MD's he doesn't take them > > from the worlds most well known artists like Sting > > (from where HJ takes mostly) or any other famous > > artists... > > Well, does anbody out here listen to rock music..I > > am talking abt the 70's and 80's...if yes has > > anybody heard Ritchie Blackmore's Deep Purple, > > Rainbow n' all that stuff....if yes again have u > > hrd the song 'Strange Kind of Woman'-Deep Purple > > and dhinthanana song from Rhythm.. > > > > well this where he has copied from ...listen closely > > to the first interlude in that Rhythm song where it > > goes like this Siru pookal...... > > Now listen to Strange Kind of Woman and note the > > tune when Blackmore sings I need You I want > > you ..........I once met a Strange Kind of Woman > > > > The tunes are exactly the same and it is the same > > tune he has used in Dilse Re except for the > > different scale and extra drag.. > > > > now there are so many such instances where our > > boss.. sorry ur boss has copied especially from > > Rolling Stones...I dunno if I shud be his fan after > > listening to all those hate comments abt HJ being a > > copycat...for that I dont like HJ too but never say > > that he is a copycat just bcoz u know he is doing > > it when u did'nt know the Master was also doing the > > same thing.. > > > > But I still like Arr for the class he owns and his > > ability to compose different types of music...but > > these days only a very few of his songs sound tooo > > good from the same album..take Swades for that ,only > > 3 songs were good...They were too good actually and > > I accept that,..but what abt Saanwariya or Aahista > > or even Dekho Na which is actually the Baba song..He > > is not he same person we saw in Roja or Taal or > > Minsara Kanavu or his old ones > > do you ever feel rahmans class in songs like Sarkara > > Inikura - New or such songs ? He is out of tunes > > these days..He is the only person whose music is > > worth listening to in the Indian cine industry but > > now that is shattered > > > > > > > > > > Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your life partneronline. > > __________________________________________________ > Do You Yahoo!? > Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around > http://mail.yahoo.com ------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> What would our lives be like without music, dance, and theater? Donate or volunteer in the arts today at Network for Good! http://us.click.yahoo.com/rKxVKC/SOnJAA/n1hLAA/iyUplB/TM --------------------------------------------------------------------~-> Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/arrahmanfans/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
