On 1/20/2010 12:49 AM India Time, _ichord_ wrote: > He is talented and has carved out a nice niche for himself. He has > great potential to be even more successful in the future. He's > very creative and very innovative. But, is he the next ARR? No, > not in my opinion.
> His music is intellectually stimulating, > diverse, and crafty, but so far, from what I've heard in Aamir and > Dev D, his music does not reach me emotionally much, does not touch > me deep inside, does not impress me with overall sound, and lacks > the type of ambiance and soul that I most prefer and appreciate in > music in general. Just my opinion. I share that opinion. Seems that is why I have not included him yet in the list of my favs. Comedy songs also become hit, technically amazing songs also become hit, but what makes a composer beloved of the listeners is thru songs that touch the heart of the listeners. Bringing this thread back to ARR, there was a time when people had started saying "ALL ARR SONGS SOUNDS ALIKE." Of course, those listeners had not given enough time for these songs to grow on them to understand the difference, but, let's remember that listener is the king and the end judge. So, when the Latka Jhatka, maya machindra telephone pole Hindi lyrics of Hindustani combined with a music that has technical wizardry more than it had melody, listeners didn't feel like exploring it at all and rejected that. Since those days, ARR has improvised in many ways so that no one now says any bad thing about ARR's music. I think Amit trivedi also has to improvised in similar way. Dev D's music was more a comedy. It is not a drawback of Amit, it is just that the movie needed such type of music and he has given that. He may be having capability to give melodious heart touching songs, but, that is yet to be shown. Gulal is an example where compositions were melodious heart touching, kudos to Piyush. Amit Trivedi has to do films having this genre of music to get taken seriously. currently he is and MD for the hip-hop-pop generation. > He should be given credit for what he's done so far, but should not > be compared to ARR as ARR is on a different plane altogether in my > view. -- Rawat > > --- In [email protected], Rahmaniac.com™ <farsad...@...> > wrote: >> Hope Amit Trivedi can maintain the consistency. I did love Ismail >> Darbar first, but then :( >> >> On Tue, Jan 19, 2010 at 10:28 AM, Anil Nair <rhythmca...@...> >> wrote: >> >>> >>> More than agree Sreekar. Amit Trivedi is special .... This is >>> one more who I have started throwing into this category >>> lately....Mickey J Meyer. >>> >>> And of course both of them are ardent devotees of AR :-) That >>> helps ... >>> >>> Good one chord ...pretty decent this ... >>> >>> -A >>> >>> >>> On Mon, Jan 18, 2010 at 12:54 PM, sreekar8191986 >>> <sreekar8191...@... >>>> wrote: >>>> >>>> i dont know how many of you agree with me..but after rahman >>>> .. i feel its happening again with Amit Trivedi...the same >>>> kind of excitement with his each song.....what a >>>> composer!!...i am eagerly waiting for his full album... >>>> >>>> >>>> --- In [email protected] >>>> <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, "ichord" <purevibz@> wrote: >>>> >>>>> Just heard some songs from the movie "Striker" composed by >>>>> various >>>> MDs/artists. I liked several of the songs. If you get a >>>> chance listen to "Cham Cham" sung by Sonu Nigam, "Haq Se" >>>> (Yuvan's Hindi Debut), "Yun Hua Raat" (Vishal B - sounds a >>>> lot in mood like Kaminey Title Song), "Maula", and "Pia >>>> Saanvara" (Sunhidi Chauhan). Very interesting and engaging >>>> music!!! >>>> >>> >>> -- -A http://viewsnmuse.blogspot.com >>> >>> >>> >> >> >> -- Farzad Khaleel www.rahmaniac.com
