I beg to differ about DevD's lyrics. I thought they were deep except the emotional atyachar song. It was just that it was packaged in a different style. Anyways, that's a seperate discussion that need not conducted under the auspices of this forum
Warm Regards ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Vinayak http://www.flickr.com/photos/rightplacerighttime/ On Thu, Jan 21, 2010 at 12:25 AM, V S Rawat <[email protected]> wrote: > > > On 1/20/2010 12:49 AM India Time, _ichord_ wrote: > > > He is talented and has carved out a nice niche for himself. He has > > great potential to be even more successful in the future. He's > > very creative and very innovative. But, is he the next ARR? No, > > not in my opinion. > > > His music is intellectually stimulating, > > diverse, and crafty, but so far, from what I've heard in Aamir and > > Dev D, his music does not reach me emotionally much, does not touch > > me deep inside, does not impress me with overall sound, and lacks > > the type of ambiance and soul that I most prefer and appreciate in > > music in general. Just my opinion. > > I share that opinion. Seems that is why I have not included him yet in > the list of my favs. > > Comedy songs also become hit, technically amazing songs also become > hit, but what makes a composer beloved of the listeners is thru songs > that touch the heart of the listeners. > > Bringing this thread back to ARR, there was a time when people had > started saying "ALL ARR SONGS SOUNDS ALIKE." Of course, those > listeners had not given enough time for these songs to grow on them to > understand the difference, but, let's remember that listener is the > king and the end judge. So, when the Latka Jhatka, maya machindra > telephone pole Hindi lyrics of Hindustani combined with a music that > has technical wizardry more than it had melody, listeners didn't feel > like exploring it at all and rejected that. Since those days, ARR has > improvised in many ways so that no one now says any bad thing about > ARR's music. > > I think Amit trivedi also has to improvised in similar way. Dev D's > music was more a comedy. It is not a drawback of Amit, it is just that > the movie needed such type of music and he has given that. He may be > having capability to give melodious heart touching songs, but, that is > yet to be shown. Gulal is an example where compositions were melodious > heart touching, kudos to Piyush. Amit Trivedi has to do films having > this genre of music to get taken seriously. currently he is and MD for > the hip-hop-pop generation. > > > > He should be given credit for what he's done so far, but should not > > be compared to ARR as ARR is on a different plane altogether in my > > view. > > -- > Rawat > > > > > > --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > Rahmaniac.com™ <farsad...@...> > > wrote: > >> Hope Amit Trivedi can maintain the consistency. I did love Ismail > >> Darbar first, but then :( > >> > >> On Tue, Jan 19, 2010 at 10:28 AM, Anil Nair <rhythmca...@...> > >> wrote: > >> > >>> > >>> More than agree Sreekar. Amit Trivedi is special .... This is > >>> one more who I have started throwing into this category > >>> lately....Mickey J Meyer. > >>> > >>> And of course both of them are ardent devotees of AR :-) That > >>> helps ... > >>> > >>> Good one chord ...pretty decent this ... > >>> > >>> -A > >>> > >>> > >>> On Mon, Jan 18, 2010 at 12:54 PM, sreekar8191986 > >>> <sreekar8191...@... > >>>> wrote: > >>>> > >>>> i dont know how many of you agree with me..but after rahman > >>>> .. i feel its happening again with Amit Trivedi...the same > >>>> kind of excitement with his each song.....what a > >>>> composer!!...i am eagerly waiting for his full album... > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com> > >>>> <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, "ichord" <purevibz@> wrote: > >>>> > >>>>> Just heard some songs from the movie "Striker" composed by > >>>>> various > >>>> MDs/artists. I liked several of the songs. If you get a > >>>> chance listen to "Cham Cham" sung by Sonu Nigam, "Haq Se" > >>>> (Yuvan's Hindi Debut), "Yun Hua Raat" (Vishal B - sounds a > >>>> lot in mood like Kaminey Title Song), "Maula", and "Pia > >>>> Saanvara" (Sunhidi Chauhan). Very interesting and engaging > >>>> music!!! > >>>> > >>> > >>> -- -A http://viewsnmuse.blogspot.com > >>> > >>> > >>> > >> > >> > >> -- Farzad Khaleel www.rahmaniac.com > > >
