> > Wow, at the end, it's a lot of changes... I started this thinking I > would spend 10 minutes on it, and here we are 8 hours later. :D Looking > forward to know what you think of the changes! >
[David] Well I can see that, it's great ! From the appraisals I've seen at my previous jobs, what we have here really outstands it. Our company does not even exist yet and we already have a top notch appraisal process, let's have the same quality for our game and we're good to go :) Not much to add to it, I look forward to see this process used and how contributors can benefit from it. Very few comments : - for you, the global rating is the mathematical average of all ratings or is a more subjective average ? (For instance, let's say the mathematical is 'solid' but almost 'strong', but overall the improvement during the 6 months has been so noticeable that the reviewer wants to push for a strong for his global rating). - you include a community rating and reviewer rating. I guess the community rating is the 360 ? Is there for you a final and unique rating (between reviewer and community) or not ? (might be useful if we link again the rating with a bonus at some point) - I compared your 'general assessment' and the 'general competencies' draft I had prepared. Yours is much more complete, there is only a ' Act with the consumer and the market in mind' in mine that I think is useful and that I did not find in yours. _______________________________________________ Hackit Bar mailing list - [email protected] Wiki: http://community.hackit.cx/ List: http://community.hackit.cx/ml/ Forum: http://community.hackit.cx/forum/ Ideas: http://community.hackit.cx/ideas/ IRC: irc://irc.freenode.net/#politis
