On Thu, 2010-08-26 at 09:05 +0200, david blanchard wrote:
> [David] Well I can see that, it's great ! From the appraisals I've seen at
> my previous jobs, what we have here really outstands it. Our company does
> not even exist yet and we already have a top notch appraisal process, let's
> have the same quality for our game and we're good to go :)
Glad you like it : )
> - for you, the global rating is the mathematical average of all ratings or
> is a more subjective average ? (For instance, let's say the mathematical is
> 'solid' but almost 'strong', but overall the improvement during the 6 months
> has been so noticeable that the reviewer wants to push for a strong for his
> global rating).
It's subjective - ratings are more a way to get a point across and get a
discussion started than really a grade.
> - you include a community rating and reviewer rating. I guess the community
> rating is the 360 ? Is there for you a final and unique rating (between
> reviewer and community) or not ? (might be useful if we link again the
> rating with a bonus at some point)
It's 360 yep.
The final rating is the reviewer rating - the self and community ratings
are elements that the reviewer takes into account in his grade, but the
final word is on him. Of course, if the reviewer does a good job, the
final grade should reflect the discussions and opinions of the different
people involved in the review process.
> - I compared your 'general assessment' and the 'general competencies' draft
> I had prepared. Yours is much more complete, there is only a ' Act with the
> consumer and the market in mind' in mine that I think is useful and that I
> did not find in yours.
Yup - please feel free to add it. We'll also probably progressively
adapt it when we actually use it.
Which makes me think of the next steps:
1. Finish defining the recurring contractor status and criterias,
that is linked to the review process
2. Write a job description for all recurring contractor positions
3. Define project objectives for the next 6 months
4. Then get the first round of review process started
Still quite some work to do, but it will be really worth it imho.
Xavier.
_______________________________________________
Hackit Bar mailing list - [email protected]
Wiki: http://community.hackit.cx/
List: http://community.hackit.cx/ml/
Forum: http://community.hackit.cx/forum/
Ideas: http://community.hackit.cx/ideas/
IRC: irc://irc.freenode.net/#politis
