On 06/08/17 22:40 , David Anderson wrote: > Testing a feature in isolation is not the same as testing the system.
True. > No one is advocating committing untested or buggy code into master. Yet it happens most of the time, mostly because *development* happens in master. And even if one sees a seldom feature branch for development it's more often than not merged to master after incomplete feature testing (e.g. not even a full build on all platforms). In any case master is broken. > However, feature testing doesn't mean that master is stable. Right, but it should be as stable as possible which requires a continuous improvement effort. Why is it broken and what can you do to actively avoid it next time? > For that, we need to do system-level testing in a separate release branch. You're right that system-level (a.k.a. integration) testing should take place in a *specific* branch. However that branch should be master in our opinion. As Laurence pointed out: release branches are to stabilize and fix releases. I agree with Bernd: can it be that your resistance to use master for integration just stems from the fact that you don't like developing in feature branches because you're still used to CVS or SVN, and in your mind branching and merging still is a pain? > This is what we've done for years with the client software. Thing is, it's probably time to reconsider your view on BOINC. That "we" means 2-3 developers running their "own" project. BOINC is different now, at least it officially wants to be. You said BOINC is now a community project. If you really mean it, then please listen to the community. From what I can tell, the community is in agreement on how things should be done nowadays. Why are you opposing *all* of us? Also, you haven't yet given any concrete arguments/reasons why the model we propose *really* wouldn't work. So far, you stated personal impressions/facts that were often misinformed or in fact unrelated to what we discussed. All of this could be resolved constructively, it would just take some open mindedness. Please consider this: when you're thinking "why is everyone but me headed in the wrong direction?", it's probably about time to reconsider you own course. Best, Oliver
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
_______________________________________________ boinc_dev mailing list boinc_dev@ssl.berkeley.edu https://lists.ssl.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/boinc_dev To unsubscribe, visit the above URL and (near bottom of page) enter your email address.
