> > > No, I think it is mostly due to training and nutrition.
> > > That's why I chose just before opening day. There
> > > wouldn't be time to learn the new techniques. Indeed,
> > > I'd argue that there may not be enough time when someone
> > > is 21. IIRC, ball players use to use spring training
> > > to get in shape. Now most are in shape when they
> > > arrive.
> > >
> >
> >
> > Doesn't that make the comparison rather meaningless though?
>
> Why? There are probably 100 people with the genes to be a top ball player
> today for every one that is one who didn't have the training, the
> dedication, the luck with injuries, etc. that the ones on top do. Is it
> meaningless to say that Barry Bonds is the top baseball player this year,
> when 100 people had the same genes to be? Or, is it meaningless to say that
> today's computers are a lot faster than the old VAX 11/780?
It is very meaningful to say that Barry Bonds is the best hitter this year. Given the
record for his career he is one of the best players of this era. It would not
meaningful to say that since he hit 72 home runs he is better than Babe Ruth
>
> Dan M.
