<< I read a report that he could face charges of treason, murder and 
conspiracy, but that 
sounds way out of line to me.  If an American kid had enlisted in the Nazi 
army, would he have been charged with treason and murder? How many 
Confederate soldiers (just about all of whom were U.S. Americans) were tried 
for such crimes? >>

There were very few treason trials after the Civil War because Lincoln and 
Grant didn't want them. However, Jefferson Davis was jailed, and he, Lee, and 
other prominent Southerners were stripped of their US citizenship.

Someone who fought for the Nazis would certainly have been charged with 
treason. Why wouldn't he? I think Walker could be charged with treason, and I 
think he should. He was in a situation in which he might have killed US 
soldiers - how is that not treason?

He has the right to his convictions, however abominable, but he also has the 
responsibility to accept the consequences. It's one thing to be a fanatic 
Muslim fundamentalist who believes the Taliban were the only true strong 
Muslim government on Earth; it's another thing to take up arms against your 
own country. He never renounced his US citizenship, as he certainly could 
have. That makes his actions treasonous, IMO.


Tom Beck

Tom Beck


"I always knew I'd see the first man on the Moon. I didn't realize I'd also 
see the last." - Jerry Pournelle

Reply via email to