Sorry I don' have the e-mail, I got a historical piece about the Civil Air
Patrol. German U-boats were parked right off the eastern AND gulf coasts,
sinking boats with impunity before Dec. 1941. They even sank boats in the
St. Lawarence and Conneticut rivers. Without Pearl Harbor, don't you think
that America would have eventually gone to war in Europe? Even assuming the
CAP work as it did, u-boats would still sink American boats in the shipping
lanes or near England. I figure some point would be reached where America
wouldn't take it any more.

Kevin T.
A little knowledge......

Well, it's hard to know.  Yes, probably, but would it have been soon enough?
Certainly the US was very heavily favoring Britain from far before the
declaration of war.  It was egregiously in violation of neutrality and did
all sorts of strange things.  Most amusingly, the US declared Iceland part
of North America in order to legally justify extending its convoy coverage
out to Iceland in the Atlantic, considerably relieving the burden on Great
Britain.  Which is actually the bit of trivia behind one of my best old Quiz
Bowl war stories, actually.  It's my guess that we _certainly_ would have
entered the war had Britain itself been invaded, and probably would have
entered by mid-1942 under any circumstances, but the determination to press
for a complete victory was probably at least partly a result of Pearl
Harbor.  At any rate, without massive American logistical support, plus the
effects of the allied strategic bombing campaign (which were in my opinion
more significant than they are often given credit for being, but that's a
huge debate for another forum) one wonders if the results in late 1941 and
early 1942 on the Eastern Front might have been very different.

Gautam

Reply via email to