<< But how, Tom?  From where I'm looking, they've done just about all they 
can reasonably do to make peace and have been rebuffed.  How do you make 
peace with an enemy that will accept no peace that does not include your 
own destruction?  How do you make peace with people that teach their 
children from the day they are born to hate you?  How do you make peace 
with people that would sooner blow themselves to kingdom come rather 
than concede that you have a right to exist?

The only path to peace that I can envision at this point is one that 
guarantees that the tactics of terror will not succeed. >>


See, there is no such thing. And I know it will be extremely difficult. 
Neither side seems willing to recognize the humanity and basic rights of the 
other. But this stalemate is far too dangerous and deadly to go on, even if 
it were possible for either side to sustain it without beginning to suffer 
severe consequences (economic collapse, post-traumatic stress on a monumental 
scale, etc.) If this continues, Israel can expect to start seeing things like 
emigration, money flowing outward, etc. Life for the Palestinians will become 
intolerable and you'll start seeing increased crime, increased domestic 
violence, increased suicide (and not just by bombers), etc. 

As the party with the established, democratic government and functioning 
economy, I think Israel has the responsibility to take the lead, no matter 
how painful it may be, no matter how unbearable it may be to seem to give 
Hamas, etc., a victory. But I think Israel's survival as a state, not to 
mention its duty as a Jewish entity, demands that Israel take certain steps, 
including unilateral withdrawal of its troops back to the Israeli border, and 
dismantling of as many settlements as it can. Then, just tell the 
Palestinians that they can have their state, build a huge fence to separate 
the two, and let the Palestinians screw things up on their own, unable to 
blame the Israelis for all their problems (which they will continue to do 
anyway). I know it can't be that easy, but they have to start doing 
something. It is horrible for me to watch Jews do these awful things to 
anyone else, regardless of the provocation or the fact that everyone else 
does things that are much much worse and the world doesn't give a shit. I 
can't worry about the rest of the world; as a Jew, all I can do is show the 
rest of you what you should be doing. That's my job as a Jew, and the 
Israelis need to summon the moral courage and physical courage to do the 
right thing. Call the Arabs' bluff, as it were, and the world's. What would 
Jeroen do if the Israelis pulled back? He'd be furious, probably, as he'd 
have to find a whole new reason to hate Jews.



Tom Beck


"I always knew I'd see the first man on the Moon. I didn't realize I'd also 
see the last." - Jerry Pournelle

Reply via email to