Nikolai Hedler <[email protected]> writes: > I cannot accept that putting a breath mark on the downbeat should ever be > the expected output, especially when that only occurs due to a grace note > in another staff (which, from what I understood, doesn't shorten the > preceding note but the following one anyways).
Grace notes in LilyPond generally shorten the preceding note. That makes them arguably not the right tool for an appoggiatura (which shortens the _following_ note at least by its nominal value). We don't have a different tool at the moment, though. > It's nonsensical to me that this should be considered intended > behavior. It's simply non-musical to assume that a breath mark is > meant to go after the bar line unless otherwise specified by the > engraver. The problem with fixing perceived bugs is that one has to be very careful not to introduce actual bugs that one can then not get rid of. -- David Kastrup
