No, they don't need to be paid for every download of their song. We as listeners to the radio can record songs off the air for personal listening (and time shifting). The radio station pays ASCAP and BMI fees (thousands per year) to play these songs.

Also, CDs and DAT tapes (and I believe hard drives now) are also taxed with a "copyright" charge that some how in some way goes towards copyrighted materials.

There is nothing under current copyright law that would prevent this. The new laws being enacted will prevent this, though, and take away most of our rights as consumers.

Jerry Johnson

>>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] 08/31/04 11:27AM >>>
Would this even be possible though? For this to be legal, the artist needs to be paid a small royalty for every download of their song. However, if their songs are streaming, and XM has no way of tracking if, when, or how often you are converting a streamed song to mp3....how would they track and pay royalties?

  ----- Original Message -----
  From: Jim Campbell
  To: CF-Community
  Sent: Tuesday, August 31, 2004 10:05 AM
  Subject: Re: Today sucks so far

  True, but I would be willing to pay more for an XM account to have the
  ability to (officially) yank music off of the stream for my library.   
  Of course it's hackable (everything is), but so are AAC's, and Apple
  hasn't yanked iTunes.  And, being able to go straight from air to iPod
  to iTunes would be terrific.

  - Jim

  <snip>
[Todays Threads] [This Message] [Subscription] [Fast Unsubscribe] [User Settings] [Donations and Support]

Reply via email to