Dave - Is the guy with whom you spoke in Virginia?  Years ago, I was
interested in a Stinson, and spoke with a guy in Virginia then
representing Franklin as some sort of distributor.  He claimed to have
some sort of approval to put modern Franklin engines in old Stinsons, to
replace the original Franklins in them.
I wasn't sold, since all he really had was the bare engine, with no
accessories or props.  His comment was basically that one should scrounge
around the wrecking yards for a prop off of a Maule, and somewhere for the
mags, starter, alternator, etc., and assemble the package yourself.  Not
the way I wanted to do it then, or now.
If they've got their act together this time, it might be a good package
STC.
However, I question the resale value of a coupe so converted.  Even though
PZL, who now owns Franklin, is an old line Polish company, and they
produce good stuff, you still have to deal with the reality of dealing
with a former eastern block nation, and their shaky economy, undependable
labor situation and U.S. distribution arrangement.
I wish that all of these problems with PZL would be solved, because the
research that I did back when I was interested in a Stinson pointed to a
good engine, but poor backup and security for future parts, etc.
Something makes me think that there already is an STC to convert Cessna
150s to this engine, and very few owners have bitten for it.
Lastly, with 50+ year old airframes, and all of the corrosion horror
stories about problems that can't be discovered even with the recent wing
AD, do we really want that much power pulling an airframe originaaly
designed for 65hp?  Might a less than proficient pilot end up exceeding
yellow line, or cruising too fast in rough air, or doing something else
that would over stress the airframe?  Just a thought to muddle.
Jerry Eichenberger
Columbus, Ohio
N2906H

<<attachment: winmail.dat>>

Reply via email to