Hello, I am hoping you might be able to help me with a small confusion -
The scope note for E80_Part_Removal<https://cidoc-crm.org/Entity/e80-part-removal/version-7.1.1> states that "This class comprises the activities that result in an instance of E18 Physical Thing being decreased by the removal of a part." This reads to me as if the relationship would then go: E80 > P112_diminished > E18, as P112 creates the connection to the thing being diminished (having something removed from it), as opposed to P113_removed, which is for the connection to the thing that was removed. However, the range of P112 is E24, not E18, and the scope note for P112_diminished<https://cidoc-crm.org/Property/p112-diminished/version-7.1.1> reads "This property identifies the instance E24 Physical Human-Made Thing that was diminished by an instance of E80 Part Removal." Meanwhile, the range of P113_removed<https://cidoc-crm.org/Property/p113-removed/version-7.1.1> is E18, as is the range of P31_has_modified<https://cidoc-crm.org/node/8121>, the superproperty of P112. It seems to me therefore that either I am reading the scope note incorrectly (very possible!) or that there is an inconsistency between the two, perhaps in the range of P112? I looked in the Issues history for anything about this, and wonder if the discussion around the change of P31 (Issue 191<https://cidoc-crm.org/Issue/ID-191-range-of-p31>) might have relevance to either the range or language around it, as in that case the range of P31 was relaxed from E24 to E18. Although, that being said, this perceived E18/E24 inconsistency as described above exists as far back as v4.0<https://cidoc-crm.org/html/cidoc_crm_v4.0.html#E80>, the earliest version available on the website, so perhaps it is my reading of the scope note that is backwards... To summarize, my question is - Which is the correct range of P112: E18 as stated in the E80 scope note or E24 as stated in the P112 scope note and range; or am I reading this set of notes/relationships incorrectly? Thanks for your guidance on this, Erin Canning
_______________________________________________ Crm-sig mailing list [email protected] http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig
