Bob Tarling wrote:

More and more my colleagues at work tell me that what they want is a
UML tool that is synchronised with the source code. ie create a UML
class will immediately create a java source file, create an attribute
in that source file will immediately update the class in the UML
diagram.

Your colleagues are wrong. Ask them if they have two windows up today, one with the java-code and one with the byte-code and if they do edits on both sides and expect them to be synched. (Now I would like to see that. On the other hand it is roumored that this is the reason IBM had to keep compatibility between their mainframe computers. People had done so many patches to the object code that the source code was no longer valid...)

Half your staff should drop java totally and concentrate on making complete models. The other part should focus on making a model to code translator that is tailored to your needs. I can already hear people protest and say that this is not possible, but it is. At work we are doing it today (not using argoUML). I know also it is being done in for instance pacemakers and set-top boxes.

If in doubt, contact Mentor and ask them for a demo of their Bridgepoint product. By the way, they are integrated with eclipse.

However I can only see the likes of NetBeans and Eclipse eventually
doing that with or without us. If its without us then who would then
need us?

Everyone like me who dislikes bloated products where integration is more important than functionality. The mentor stuff above works in the eclipse, but so far the previous version had far less bugs and were easier to use once you had learnt to use it.

/Leif


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to