Sounds good to me. Requesting from the private mailing list would ease the concerns that users' privacy (email address) would be public.
Alessandro Solimando <[email protected]> 于2022年10月26日周三 17:03写道： > It's understandable from the ASF side, and the proposal you drafted LGTM. > > I'd probably also add some instructions under > https://calcite.apache.org/develop/ > > Best regards, > Alessandro > > On Wed, 26 Oct 2022 at 10:58, Francis Chuang <[email protected]> > wrote: > > > Hello Community Members, > > > > ASF Infra has announced that contributors will no longer be able to sign > > up for a JIRA account from 6th November 2022 onward. This is due to the > > amount of spam issues and users being created in JIRA, causing a lot of > > overhead for the infra team. > > > > From the 6th of November, contributors who wish to have a JIRA account > > (to create, assign, watch, etc issues) will need to request an account > > through an ASF PMC. Note that if you already have a JIRA account, or if > > you requested an account from the PMC of a different ASF project after > > the 6th of November, you can use that account to open, watch, comment, > > etc on issues from other projects, in other words, you only need to > > request an account once from a PMC to access JIRA for all ASF projects. > > > > The Calcite PMC has had some discussion over the last few days to design > > a process for requesting a JIRA account through the Calcite project. We > > are currently proposing the following process for Calcite: > > > > 1. Contributors who wish to have a JIRA account should email a dedicated > > private mailing list (for example, [email protected]) with the > > following: > > -- Proposed JIRA username [a-z0-9] only > > -- Full display name > > -- Email address > > -- Reasons why you are requesting an account > > > > This list is private and will not be accessible via any public archives > > on the internet. > > > > Once a PMC member looks at the request, they will request the account to > > be created via ASF's system. In the event that the chosen username is > > not available, they will get back to the requestor and ask for an > > alternative username. > > > > 2. We will document the process in simple and clear steps on our > > website. This page will be linked prominently in the README.md files of > > our 3 code repositories: calcite, calcite-avatica and calcite-avatica-go. > > > > Please let us know what you think! > > > > Francis > > > -- Best, Benchao Li
