Hi François- I recall the discussion about removing the OSGi support from Camel, but I do not see it listed on the ROADMAP to Camel 4 link.
Did OSGi header support for camel jars officially get dropped? Seems like such a minor thing to keep around. -Matt > On Jan 9, 2023, at 3:19 AM, fpapon <fpa...@apache.org> wrote: > > Hi JB, > > Make sense for Cave and Winegrower. > > About Camel-Karaf, as it was announced by the Camel team in the roadmap to > Camel 4, I was thinking that it was already acted: > > https://camel.apache.org/blog/2023/01/camel4roadmap/ > > I asked the question about the OSGi bundle still provide or not by Camel team > but no clear decision, Camel team don't want to provide OSGi bundle for Camel > core anymore. > > regards, > > François > > On 09/01/2023 10:13, Jean-Baptiste Onofré wrote: >> Hi François, >> >> Thanks for bringing this discussion. >> >> Here's my personal standpoint: >> 1. Decanter: I started to work on Decanter 3.x (refactoring). I think >> we can do a release now with just updates on the collectors/appenders >> before moving forward on decanter 3.x. I propose to cut new Decanter >> release asap. >> 2. Cellar: quite the same as Decanter. I plan a refactoring, but it is >> worth doing an updated version (new hazelcast, kubernetes client, >> karaf version). Same: I propose to cut new Cellar release asp. >> 3. Cave: I think we don't have many users on Cave, maybe it's worth to >> move the project to "attic" ? >> 4. Winegrower: same as Cave, I don't think we have a lot of users, >> maybe it's worth to move the project to "attic" ? >> 5. Minho: >> 6. For SMX bundles, the objective is not to move as it is. The >> objective it's to use the new bundle descriptor I started in Pax URL. >> Karaf "Bundles" will host just the descriptor to create the bundle on >> the fly (and eventually cached). The other part of SMX (assembly + >> spec) can be moved in Karaf subproject. >> 7. For camel-karaf, I'm open to community proposals. If it's better to >> have it in Karaf, I'm OK with it (same question about jclouds-karaf). >> >> Regards >> JB >> >> On Mon, Jan 9, 2023 at 10:07 AM fpapon <fpa...@apache.org> wrote: >>> Hi, >>> >>> I want to start a thread about Apache Karaf subprojects roadmap and >>> maintainability. >>> >>> Today we have: >>> >>> - Decanter: last release on Feb. 2022 >>> >>> - Cellar: last release on Aug. 2020 >>> >>> - Cave: last release on Nov. 2019 >>> >>> We also have: >>> >>> - Winegrower: last release on Nov. 2020 >>> >>> - Minho: last release on Jan. 2023 (but plan to move to dedicated TLP >>> project) >>> >>> There is also some discussion about moving SMX bundle and Camel-Karaf as >>> Karaf subprojects so I think it will be nice to see what we would/could >>> maintain. >>> >>> regards, >>> >>> -- >>> -- >>> François >>> > -- > -- > François >
