On Sun, 2017-10-22 at 15:28 +0100, Ian Boston wrote:
> Hi,
> Good solution. One small modification to help anyone get to the old
> tree.

Well, I saw what we did at Adobe last time we had something similar :-)

> 
> Rather than switching the main branch and making it empty,  if you
> branch
> trunk to a new branch "archive" and then make trunk empty as you
> suggest,
> it will be possible to point anyone who gets a 404 to the new
> "archive"
> branch. Tagging the last commit from SVN would also help keep a
> permanent
> record.
> 
> Only those URLs that are not pointing to a commit/tag/branch (other
> than
> trunk) will be broken and the README left in trunk can explain how to
> change the URL.

I think that there are plenty of links pointing to 'trunk' though. I
have tried to make permanent links to github, but I did not do that all
the time.

So that would mean that all link to trunk would result in a 404 Not
Found, as I have tried it with [1].

So we either

a) break all links to the 'trunk' branch, or
b) leave the 'trunk' branch alive, with the added disadvantage that
navigating from a 'trunk' link leaves the impression that the
branch/repo are still in use.

Did I get this right or is there something else?

Robert

[1]: https://github.com/apache/sling/blob/archived/KEYS

Reply via email to