Hi,
I want to push this issue a bit.
What do we need to change for a new vote?
Marshall, do you want to restructure the update sites in SVN?
Best,
Peter
On 19.12.2012 14:17, Peter Klügl wrote:
Hi,
On 19.12.2012 06:27, Marshall Schor wrote:
hi,
I'm just now having a chance to look at this (sorry for the delay).
Some initial questions:
As part of this update, the UIMA SVN has a new top-level folder,
parallel with
uimaj, uima-as, etc., called eclipse-packagings.
I noticed this folder is missing the normal trunk/tags/branches
subfolders. It
would seem to me that we should have those, and when a new packaging
is done, it
would have a version, and be "tagged", like a release.
I realize it may not be considered a release (because it's just a
re-packaging
of the already released Jars) but it still seems to me that we should
have a
trunk and a tags for this, and tag what we promote out.
Another question: There's a pom at the top level of the folder
eclipse-packagings. It says its for artifact "eclipse-packagings",
and has a
version number of "4".
I would think it would have a version number of "1", since it's the
first
version being released.
I agree on all points. One thing I want to mention: We need some
strategy for the version number as this packaging will probably
contain releases with different version numbers, e.g., uima-2.4.0 and
hopefully uima-textmarker-2.0.0
Therefore the number will be increased with asynchronous releases.
Peter
More later...
-Marshall
On 11/29/2012 11:31 AM, Peter Klügl wrote:
Hi,
this vote is about replacing the current update site with a composite
repository, which essentially contains the same artifacts as before.
We discussed in UIMA-2475
(https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/UIMA-2475)
that the update site of Apache UIMA is not compatible with p2
repositories.
This complicates, for example, the development of bundles built with
Tycho.
The result of the discussion is right now a composite repository,
which refers
to two update sites. The first one is exactly the currently
published update
site (legacy) and the second one is a p2 repository (uima-2.4.0)
containing
the eclipse bundles of the 2.4.0 release. Note that these artifacts are
provided twice.
The new update site (composite repository) is here:
https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/uima/eclipse-packagings/eclipse-update-site
Please vote to approve this release:
[ ] +1 Approve the release
[ ] -1 Veto the release (please provide specific comments)
[ ] 0 Don't care
PS: As this is essentially not a new release, I skipped most/all parts
mentioned in http://uima.apache.org/release.html
