> I always thought the whole point of this vote was to get an idea which of the > three sets was the most accepted allowing us to go with a particular set and > to > then work out the issues we have with this set with its author. > > Choosing each icon by itself and thereby mixing different sets might seem the > easier solution but it doesn't help Adium's appearance. We are left with an > odd > mélange of different styles. > > So my proposal would be to choose a set and to improve it. Both George and > Bogdan have shown they are responsive and open to suggestions.
Nobody responded to this (or Paul's email prior to mine) but I'd like to see this put back on the agenda. There are two major reasons why I disagree with the selection of icons made by Evan and Zac: 1. Icons from all three sets (current, Bogdan's, George's) were chosen which results in Adium looking pretty inconsistent. (Paul elaborated on this in his email from February 27, 2011 - http://markmail.org/message/4cehenuhfiu6z3xm) 2. The choice is pretty random and doesn't reflect the results of the vote (http://wixardy.net/adiumIcons/;http://wixardy.net/adiumIcons/pics.php). We really, really need to settle on one set and go from there if we want to achieve any kind of consistency. Regards, Robbie
