On Thu, Jun 26, 2025 at 5:24 AM David Airlie <airl...@redhat.com> wrote: > > On Thu, Jun 26, 2025 at 2:55 AM Marcin Juszkiewicz > <mjuszkiew...@redhat.com> wrote: > > > > W dniu 25.06.2025 o 16:35, Stephen Smoogen pisze: > > > 1. How are you going to remove it? Everyone add a ExcludeArch: , someone > > > fix koji to only allow a specific list? a shadow koji which only builds > > > for x86_32? etc > > > > From what I read in the past I think that it would be better to rather > > have something like "IncludeArch: i686" and disable 32-bit x86 globally. > > > > The list of packages to build for i686 is probably shorter than list > > with rest of packages. > > > > glibc, toolchain, kernel headers, then things needed for infrastructure > > and needed libraries and their dependences. > > > > I'd prefer if we started with this, and work out the list of packages > that need i686 and drop the rest. > > I think starting from mesa-* and getting all the dependencies might be > a good start, but maybe we should look into cross compiling mesa i686 > from x86-64 so we can reduce it further as mesa needs a lot of python > to build. > > Now in stating that we just literally broke this with llvm in f42, so > that cross compiles were a lot more painful, but I think we've stepped > that back.
Just to provide some more information, here all mesa's non-default build dependencies that would need i686 treatment. DEBUG util.py:461: DirectX-Headers-devel i686 1.615.0-1.fc43 build 3.5 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: bindgen-cli i686 0.71.1-1.fc43 build 6.1 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: bison i686 3.8.2-10.fc43 build 3.5 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: cargo-rpm-macros noarch 26.3-4.fc42 build 14.7 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: cbindgen i686 0.28.0-1.fc43 build 4.7 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: clang-devel i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 28.5 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: elfutils-libelf-devel i686 0.193-2.fc43 build 49.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: expat-devel i686 2.7.1-1.fc43 build 202.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: flex i686 2.6.4-19.fc42 build 791.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: gcc i686 15.1.1-2.fc43 build 109.7 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: gcc-c++ i686 15.1.1-2.fc43 build 42.5 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: gettext i686 0.25-1.fc43 build 13.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: glslang i686 15.3.0-1.fc43 build 3.4 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: kernel-headers i686 6.16.0-0.rc2.24.fc43 build 6.7 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libX11-devel i686 1.8.11-1.fc42 build 1.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXdamage-devel i686 1.1.6-5.fc42 build 2.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXext-devel i686 1.3.6-3.fc42 build 98.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXfixes-devel i686 6.0.1-5.fc42 build 9.2 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXrandr-devel i686 1.5.4-5.fc42 build 21.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXxf86vm-devel i686 1.1.6-2.fc42 build 12.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libclc-devel i686 20.1.6-1.fc43 build 123.6 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libdrm-devel i686 2.4.124-2.fc42 build 708.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libglvnd-core-devel i686 1:1.7.0-7.fc42 build 40.3 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libselinux-devel i686 3.8-3.fc43 build 126.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libunwind-devel i686 1.8.1-2.fc43 build 137.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libva-devel i686 2.22.0-4.fc42 build 696.6 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libvdpau-devel i686 1.5-9.fc42 build 207.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libxcb-devel i686 1.17.0-5.fc42 build 2.7 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libxshmfence-devel i686 1.3.2-6.fc42 build 1.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libzstd-devel i686 1.5.7-1.fc43 build 208.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: llvm-devel i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 28.7 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: lm_sensors-devel i686 3.6.0-22.fc42 build 18.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: meson noarch 1.8.1-5.fc43 build 13.2 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-devel i686 3.14.0~b3-1.fc43 build 1.9 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-mako noarch 1.2.3-10.fc43 build 712.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-ply noarch 3.11-27.fc43 build 575.3 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-pycparser noarch 2.22-2.fc43 build 1.5 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-pyyaml i686 6.0.2-3.fc43 build 814.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust-paste-devel noarch 1.0.15-3.fc42 build 64.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust-proc-macro2-devel noarch 1.0.95-1.fc43 build 210.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust-quote-devel noarch 1.0.40-1.fc43 build 120.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust-syn+clone-impls-devel noarch 2.0.101-1.fc43 build 4.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust-unicode-ident-devel noarch 1.0.18-1.fc43 build 305.7 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: spirv-llvm-translator-devel i686 20.1.0-1.fc43 build 23.6 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: spirv-tools-devel i686 2025.2-1.fc43 build 164.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: valgrind-devel i686 1:3.25.1-1.fc43 build 533.7 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: vulkan-headers noarch 1.4.313.0-1.fc43 build 30.9 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: vulkan-loader-devel i686 1.4.313.0-1.fc43 build 8.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: wayland-devel i686 1.23.1-1.fc43 build 678.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: wayland-protocols-devel noarch 1.45-1.fc43 build 966.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: xorg-x11-proto-devel noarch 2024.1-4.fc42 build 1.7 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: zlib-ng-compat-devel i686 2.2.4-2.fc43 build 107.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: Installing dependencies: DEBUG util.py:461: annobin-docs noarch 12.96-1.fc43 build 98.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: annobin-plugin-gcc i686 12.96-1.fc43 build 996.6 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: cargo i686 1.87.0-2.fc43 build 26.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: cargo2rpm noarch 0.1.18-3.fc43 build 1.3 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: clang i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 397.3 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: clang-libs i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 119.7 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: clang-resource-filesystem i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 15.3 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: clang-tools-extra i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 70.6 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: cmake-filesystem i686 3.31.6-3.fc43 build 0.0 B DEBUG util.py:461: cpp i686 15.1.1-2.fc43 build 39.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: emacs-filesystem noarch 1:30.0-4.fc42 build 0.0 B DEBUG util.py:461: expat i686 2.7.1-1.fc43 build 292.6 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: gcc-plugin-annobin i686 15.1.1-2.fc43 build 59.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: gettext-envsubst i686 0.25-1.fc43 build 86.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: gettext-libs i686 0.25-1.fc43 build 2.3 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: gettext-runtime i686 0.25-1.fc43 build 451.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: glibc-devel i686 2.41.9000-16.fc43 build 2.3 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: hwdata noarch 0.396-1.fc43 build 9.5 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libX11 i686 1.8.11-1.fc42 build 1.3 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libX11-common noarch 1.8.11-1.fc42 build 1.2 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libX11-xcb i686 1.8.11-1.fc42 build 10.2 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXau i686 1.0.12-2.fc42 build 72.2 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXau-devel i686 1.0.12-2.fc42 build 7.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXdamage i686 1.1.6-5.fc42 build 42.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXext i686 1.3.6-3.fc42 build 96.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXfixes i686 6.0.1-5.fc42 build 33.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXrandr i686 1.5.4-5.fc42 build 63.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXrender i686 0.9.12-2.fc42 build 53.2 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXrender-devel i686 0.9.12-2.fc42 build 50.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libXxf86vm i686 1.1.6-2.fc42 build 28.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libasan i686 15.1.1-2.fc43 build 1.9 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libatomic i686 15.1.1-2.fc43 build 23.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libclc i686 20.1.6-1.fc43 build 72.6 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libclc-spirv i686 20.1.6-1.fc43 build 5.3 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libdrm i686 2.4.124-2.fc42 build 431.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libedit i686 3.1-55.20250104cvs.fc42 build 243.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libedit-devel i686 3.1-55.20250104cvs.fc42 build 59.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libffi-devel i686 3.5.1-1.fc43 build 33.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libgit2 i686 1.9.0-5.fc43 build 1.4 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libglvnd i686 1:1.7.0-7.fc42 build 471.7 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libglvnd-glx i686 1:1.7.0-7.fc42 build 615.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libmpc i686 1.3.1-7.fc42 build 167.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libpciaccess i686 0.16-15.fc42 build 47.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libpciaccess-devel i686 0.16-15.fc42 build 15.3 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libsepol-devel i686 3.8-1.fc42 build 120.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libssh2 i686 1.11.1-3.fc42 build 337.7 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libstdc++-devel i686 15.1.1-2.fc43 build 15.5 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libtextstyle i686 0.25-1.fc43 build 389.3 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libubsan i686 15.1.1-2.fc43 build 550.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libunwind i686 1.8.1-2.fc43 build 179.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libva i686 2.22.0-4.fc42 build 357.3 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libvdpau i686 1.5-9.fc42 build 20.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libvdpau-trace i686 1.5-9.fc42 build 76.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libwayland-client i686 1.23.1-1.fc43 build 53.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libwayland-cursor i686 1.23.1-1.fc43 build 32.3 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libwayland-egl i686 1.23.1-1.fc43 build 11.7 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libwayland-server i686 1.23.1-1.fc43 build 77.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libxcb i686 1.17.0-5.fc42 build 1.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: libxcrypt-devel i686 4.4.38-7.fc43 build 30.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libxshmfence i686 1.3.2-6.fc42 build 11.7 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: libyaml i686 0.2.5-16.fc42 build 129.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: llhttp i686 9.3.0-4.fc43 build 91.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: llvm i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 94.8 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: llvm-filesystem i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 0.0 B DEBUG util.py:461: llvm-googletest i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 2.1 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: llvm-libs i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 142.8 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: llvm-static i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 313.6 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: llvm-test i686 20.1.6-9.fc43 build 2.2 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: lm_sensors-libs i686 3.6.0-22.fc42 build 81.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: m4 i686 1.4.20-1.fc43 build 847.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: make i686 1:4.4.1-10.fc42 build 1.8 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: mesa-dri-drivers i686 25.1.3-2.fc43 build 50.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: mesa-filesystem i686 25.1.3-2.fc43 build 3.6 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: mesa-libGL i686 25.1.3-2.fc43 build 337.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: mesa-libgbm i686 25.1.3-2.fc43 build 18.9 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: mpdecimal i686 4.0.1-1.fc43 build 216.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: ncurses-c++-libs i686 6.5-6.20250614.fc43 build 144.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: ncurses-devel i686 6.5-6.20250614.fc43 build 893.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: ninja-build i686 1.12.1-5.fc43 build 473.8 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: pcre2-devel i686 10.45-1.fc43 build 2.1 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: pcre2-utf16 i686 10.45-1.fc43 build 621.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: pcre2-utf32 i686 10.45-1.fc43 build 593.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: pyproject-rpm-macros noarch 1.18.1-1.fc43 build 114.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python-pip-wheel noarch 25.1.1-4.fc43 build 1.2 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: python-rpm-macros noarch 3.14-1.fc43 build 22.1 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3 i686 3.14.0~b3-1.fc43 build 28.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-libs i686 3.14.0~b3-1.fc43 build 42.5 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-markupsafe i686 3.0.2-3.fc43 build 60.6 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-packaging noarch 25.0-3.fc43 build 607.5 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-rpm-generators noarch 14-12.fc42 build 81.7 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-rpm-macros noarch 3.14-1.fc43 build 6.4 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: python3-setuptools noarch 78.1.1-7.fc43 build 9.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust i686 1.87.0-2.fc43 build 111.8 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust-std-static i686 1.87.0-2.fc43 build 137.8 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust-syn-devel noarch 2.0.101-1.fc43 build 2.1 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: rust-unicode-ident+default-devel noarch 1.0.18-1.fc43 build 2.0 KiB DEBUG util.py:461: spirv-llvm-translator i686 20.1.0-1.fc43 build 4.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: spirv-tools-libs i686 2025.2-1.fc43 build 6.0 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: tzdata noarch 2025b-1.fc43 build 1.6 MiB DEBUG util.py:461: vim-filesystem noarch 2:9.1.1435-1.fc43 build 40.0 B DEBUG util.py:461: vulkan-loader i686 1.4.313.0-1.fc43 build 575.8 KiB > > Dave. -- _______________________________________________ devel mailing list -- devel@lists.fedoraproject.org To unsubscribe send an email to devel-le...@lists.fedoraproject.org Fedora Code of Conduct: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/project/code-of-conduct/ List Guidelines: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines List Archives: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@lists.fedoraproject.org Do not reply to spam, report it: https://pagure.io/fedora-infrastructure/new_issue
