On Mon, 13 Jan 2003, David Dawes wrote:

>>David, this is wonderful news.  I'm very pleased to see this 
>>change happen.  I've wondered for a long time why the private 
>>devel list was private, considering almost if not all of the 
>>discussions that have taken place on it in all the time I've been 
>>on it have not really been something that private.
>
>Well right there you missed something.  Everything on the
>private devel was private.  There was nothing there that could
>be repeated, nor still can for that matter.  Everything said
>there was done and spoken in confidence and honour.

Sorry, that's not what I meant.  My bad.  Indeed the list was 
private, and so what was said on it was private, and was indeed 
spoken with confidence.

What I meant rather, is that a large amount of the discussions on
there, while private when they did occur, weren't something IMHO
that couldn't have been public had the list been public.  I've
always been of the opinion that the devel list appeared to be
used more as a way to say things without generating extremely 
long threads that drag in people that aren't even developers to 
give their 2 cents too.

Having the list public now, will show wether or not it ever 
mattered I guess (except of course for things that were discussed 
that were indeed private and confidential and concerned with 
non-public information perhaps under NDA or whatnot).

>>In the past I have also submitted various patches found on 
>>mailing lists, and things people have sent me that fixed 
>>something for them.  A great deal of said patches I merely passed 
>>along upstream in hopes that they might be useful to the project 
>>after someone did a good code review.  This was somewhat of a 
>>mistake of course, as I had no idea what was expected, and found 
>>out quite some time later that my processes and procedures for 
>>submitting patches was not entirely the best.
>
>That is correct.

Thanks for acknowledging this.

-- 
Mike A. Harris


_______________________________________________
Devel mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://XFree86.Org/mailman/listinfo/devel

Reply via email to