On Nov 28, 2008, at 9:45 AM, Laurent Lunati wrote: > I vote +1 for 4, and i don't consider 3 as a valid proposal
Could you explain why? Thanks -Vincent > Le 28 nov. 08 à 08:31, Marius Dumitru Florea a écrit : > >> I'm not a big fan of step wizards thus I'm more into proposal 3. See >> other comments below. >> >> Jean-Vincent Drean wrote: >>> On Thu, Nov 27, 2008 at 8:02 PM, Vincent Massol >>> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >>>> Re the image selection: >>>> * It would be much much better to see the images before choosing >>>> them >>>> (the preview comes too late). You cannot choose an image on its >>>> name >>>> alone that's too hard. >>> >>> The only solution I see for this is to have a tooltip with a preview >>> in the treeview. >> >> The user would be forced to use the mouse in order to see the >> preview. >> >>> >>>> * What is the camera icon doing? Is it just an image? >>> >>> Yes. >>> >>>> * How do I enter advanced parameters for images? >>> >>> This mockup is about the wiki explorer, I've put the example of the >>> image insertion but this part is not to be taken as a proposal. >>> >>>> Apart from this it looks good to me but I still have a small >>>> preference for 3 since >>>> - as a user I prefer to see all options to understand where I'll >>>> find >>>> the feature I'm looking for >>> >>> s/user/power user/ >> >> The WYSIWYG addresses power users also. >> >>> >>>> - it's one click less >>> >>> IMHO an extra click is only a problem if the user has to think where >>> to click and why to click. >>> I agree that 2 or more extra clicks are a problem but only one, with >>> the action button always at the very same place, no. >> >> What I find sometimes annoying is going back and forth through a >> wizard. >> I admit a wizard fills more secure the first few times it's being >> used, >> but for me it can get annoying the more I'm using it. >> >> So I'm more into proposal 3, but I'm not against 4. >> >> Thanks, >> Marius >> >>> >>>> Re your arguments below we can have the same with option 3. >>> >>> I don't think so, actually that's why I came up with 4). >>> >>> JV. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
