It appears that Richard Clayton <[email protected]> said: >An end-user's opinion of the value of a mailing list to them is hardly a >good signal for a mailbox provider to use in assessing a remote site's >authentication practices.
We seem to have serious confusion here (not by you) between the security and/or authentication issues of a mailing list, and those of the mail systems that the list's subscribers user. For the lists I know, the main issue they worry about is whether signups are real, which they usually check by sending a confirmation message to the signed up address. The OAuth stuff does this in a way that can happen entirely in the user's browser, which I think most people would prefer to waiting for something to show up in their mailbox. A separate issue that they should pay attention to but usually don't is whether list mail purporting to be from a subscriber actually is from that person. A separate question is how mail systems decide to accept mail from list hosts. The mail systems I know do not try to assess a remote site's authentication practices. They look to see whether it's sending mail its users want, based on the usual spam filtering signals. If I order something online, I give the vendor an address so it can send me receipts and shipping info, and more often than not it will then send me ads until I tell it to stop. In that transaction they never try to verify the address beyond asking people to type it in twice, since there's little reason for people to lie. We really do want the receipt. There's basicallly no authentication practice, and that's fine. R's, John nn _______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
