On 20/05/2026 19:28, John R. Levine wrote:
On Wed, 20 May 2026, Alessandro Vesely wrote:
[...]
[Using OAuth to authorize mailing list forwarding] seems to imply
a shift away from traditional subscribe-by-email workflows, since
the authorization step depends on an interactive web/ OAuth
exchange.>
Um, in case you haven't noticed, the vast majority of mailing list
management happens via web pages and has for many years. Signups
usually send a confirmation message but that's after the user signs up
on the web.
A confirmation message is also commonly sent when signing up by email,
and it often allows confirmation either via web or by replying to the
message. With an OAuth-based flow, however, an additional confirmation
step would presumably become unnecessary.
My main point, though, is that each authorized mailing list message
would still need to carry some form of authentication. One advantage of
ARC in this context is that it can expose the mailing list's DMARC
handling policy. For example, an AAR field showing dmarc=fail on mail
forwarded from a domain publishing p=reject could reasonably be
considered relevant information for downstream handling or abuse analysis.
It is interesting to consider whether ARC would have taken a different
direction if mechanisms for explicit authorization between MLMs and MBPs
had already existed at the time. ARC effectively assumes a degree of
trust in intermediaries, while these approaches appear to make that
trust relationship explicit.
From the user's point of view it's not very different from what they do
now, except that they don't have to switch to their mail app to do the
confirmations.
Improving the user experience is probably the strongest argument in
favor of this approach. At the same time, since authorization
effectively establishes a relationship between the MLM and the MBP,
there seem to be a number of additional operational details to address
—though those are probably off-topic here.
Many list managers still support mail sub/unsub but nobody uses it any
more.
Some do, for example: https://netfilter.org/mailinglists.html#ml-user
Best
Ale
--
_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]