As I've been reading the forums, and exploring d-star and it's uses it seems as
though there is some serious "infighting" between those using dplus, and those
using other methods such as dextra, rtpdir, and other software implementations
of d-star. The debate has gotten so heated, that it is causing some bitter
factions. As a "user" of d-star I understand what it does, and why it does
what it does, and I know how to make it work from a users perspective.
>From reading the forums it seems that this debate is over security of the
>currently working d-star network. Repeater owners, gateway admins, and the
>trust server admins are concerned that the expermental open source software
>can crash their gateways when they have spent lots of time and effort in
>making sure that this system that we know and love is d-star in it's current
>form,works affectively.
The open source software developers are concerned that this approach flys in
the face of the experimentation aspect of ham radio and d-star's development.
What if an "x" module were reated on the repeater stacks? This could be
virtual, or could have the ability to be placed on a repeater if desired.
However, this "x" module could be done in such a way that if it crashed would
not affect the gateway, but still give communication access to the current
d-star network.
Also what atempt has been made to develope a standard framework for d-star
software develop, and the use of d-star: when to use linking/unlinking, or
callsign routing etc?
Developing a "d-star compliant standard would give everybody some guidelines in
which to develop alternatives to dplus if desired, while still being
interoperable. f I'm not on the right page, pleas feel free to correct me, but
I don't see how calling people frauds dictators, due to dplus and the dvdongle
and attacking people's natonalism is going to get us anywhere. We're all
pioneering a method of communication that is too new for this stuff. What can
I the d-star proponent/ user do to help bring both sides to the table? If we
don't resolve this d-star will never take off.
---- Msg sent via Cox.net- http://cox.net
