> Yes I am watching the list.  I do have a lot of foreign
> mail isp's blocked to get rid of the spam.  Don't even
> know this person.  I will unblock the .ca but if I get more
> spam from them, I will turn the block back on.  I might
> just have to leave the list.

I should probably preface my remarks by stating that, as a Canadian, I 
find it really offensive that anybody would see the .ca top level domain 
as a major source of spam. For my own inbox, only one Canadian ISP 
(sjrb.ca, if I remember correctly, or it might be srjb.ca) has been the 
source of more than one or two spam messages sent to me, so it would be a 
lot more discriminating to block that one ISP than a whole country. (I 
will grant you that blocking mail from Argentina, Brazil, China, Korea, 
the Philippines, and Russia would block a significant amount of spam, at 
least if my experience is anything to go by.)

Besides all of which, in my experience, virtually all spam comes with 
forged headers, so filtering on the "From:" line is the next thing to 
useless. As it happens, I'm on the team responsible for defening a 
large-ish E-mail network against spam, viruses, and so on, and we have 
found it necessary to use multiple filtering rules to distinguish between 
genuine E-mail and spam, and we're having to adjust those filters all the 
time. A single strategy for filtering mail can only work for so long, 
and, as in this case, only at the expense of a high number of "false 
positives." (Of course, if you have all the business you can handle, 
false positives might not be a concern to you.)

One strategy which I really like, but which might not work for mailing 
lists like this, is to use a service like, say, bluebottle.com, which 
sends first-time senders a message asking them to hit a web site and 
verify that they're a real person. Since spam is almost invariably sent 
with forged headers, the spammer never gets the message and thus can't 
whitelist themselves. (And if they did, you can almost blacklist them.) 
Unfortunately, bluebottle.com is one of the E-mail services which plays 
what I call "Cutesy Domain Games", and thus I can't pick up from it with 
an unpatched version of Emailer, and I have not yet found a version of 
Emailer which will patch successfully on my machine. (I am referring to 
the "double @" patch which Chris told me about. I sure hope he gets that 
dead machine fixed, so he can send me a prepatched copy, as it would make 
my life considerably easier.)

Greg


Greg Slade                              www.associate.com/camsoc/greg/
[EMAIL PROTECTED]                            www.associate.com/camsoc/ots/
"To the man who only has a hammer, everything he encounters begins to
look like a nail."                                 - Abraham H. Maslow


___________________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe send a mail message with a SUBJECT line of "unsubscribe" to
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>  or  <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Reply via email to