Chris,

The "blame" for standards can be assessed everywhere. But you posted:

  >> ...how we stood by and let the power generating industry make the 
  >> consumer responsible for the supply quality. 

The problem here is that the industry can't control what we hang on the line.  
Remember Tungar (TM) half-wave rectifier battery chargers? Direct connection 
across the line? With enough DC component on your neighborhood step-down 
transformer, it goes up in flames.  There's no way your local power generating 
authority or company (depending where you are) can adjust things at the 
generating end to accommodate all the user loads. They do very well to keep the 
power running as it is. 

We had some officials of Southern California Edison (our power company) at our 
radio club meeting a couple of months ago to talk about the last wide-area power
blackout, how it happened and how it was dealt with.  They did not try to evade 
due responsibility, or invent technical explanations with which to befuddle us. 
It was an impressive presentation.  Bottom line, the power generating people 
have to run to keep up with conditions we impose on them.  Some things, such as 
three-phase harmonic imbalance, they cannot correct...and there's where we get 
power quality limitations. 

Perhaps those are someone's "fault".  I don't think one can assign blame, 
however. It's something we have to accept if we want to keep getting power under
the conditions we have been used to.

Cheers,

Cortland

Reply via email to