George, I haven't seen that many water locusts, but your tree looks much more like honey locust to me. Water locust can be just has thorny, but typically has much less platy bark than honey locust. Honey locust grows in floodplains at the same elevation as sycamore and cottonwood while water locust grows in depressions in floodplains, in the southeast associating with water elm. Also, all of the water locusts I have seen were rather stout trees, so the dimensions you list seem to fit honey locust better.
Jess On Sat, Aug 1, 2009 at 5:15 PM, George Fieo<[email protected]> wrote: > Dale, > > > > I measured a honey locust at Valley Forge National Park that is 3’11” x > 103.3’. Now that I’m looking at it’s pictures I’m not so sure that it’s a > honey locust but possibly a water locust, which would be way out of it’s > native range. Anything is possible along the river. Let me know what you > think. > > > > George > > > > From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On > Behalf Of Dale Luthringer > Sent: Friday, July 31, 2009 11:11 PM > To: [email protected] > Subject: [ENTS] Re: Cedar Hollow Preserve, Pa. > > > > Great job, George!!! > > > > That hackberry blows away the rest in terms in height. That'll be a tough > one to beat. > > > > Your honey locust and Norway maple are the tallest documented in PA... but > we have very few in the database, so these could change. > > > > Sorry it's taken me so long to reply. I'm slowly getting to my data backlog > and wanted to get this in my list of PA RI sites. > > > > Thanks! > > > > Dale > > On Wed, Apr 1, 2009 at 3:52 PM, George Fieo <[email protected]> wrote: > > ENTS, > > > > On 3/14/09, my son and I stopped by the Cedar Hollow Preserve located in > Tredyffrin Township, Chester Co., Pa. The preserve has a total of 67 acres > containing open fields, flood plain, and wooded areas on steep slopes > overlooking two streams, Cedar Hollow Run and Valley Creek. This site has > lots of invasives with the slopes and ridges having little to none. The > preserve was once a farm site and the old fields are full of honey locust. > Church Rd. runs through the preserve dividing it into two sections, east and > west. The east side is mostly open field and flood plain while the west > side is completely wooded. > > > > The first tree we measured was a huge sycamore just south of the parking > lot. It is the largest tree on the preserve at 19’5” x 107.2 x 119.5. > This is the largest sycamore of four that had a 14’+ cbh. We then crossed > Church Rd. and headed into the west side of the preserve. Tulip poplars > dominate the canopy along with ash(green or white), red oak, sugar maple, > and fewer bitternut hickory. Halfway up the north slope was a large fallen > red oak with a 15’+ cbh. From here we walked the top of the ridge to the > southwest corner of the preserve where we found an eastern red cedar. From > where I stood the tree looked dead but it’s top was green. A closer look > revealed that one side of the trunk had no bark but the back side did. It > reminds me of a bristle cone pine. The cedar measured 6’1” x 48. Then we > headed back, northeast along the ridge, and came across a small flat that > had a few chinkapin oaks. Just below the flat was a fat bitternut hickory > that measured 8’2” x 99.9. We were now on the south facing slope and found > some more bitternut hickories and the tallest was 6’9” x 114.4. We measured > a few more trees before crossing back over Church Rd. and into the east side > of the preserve. > > > > The east side is dominated by honey locust along with boxelder, black > walnut, sycamore, and ash except for a small ridge in the northeast corner > that has the same forest type as the west side of the preserve. Here we > came across some short but fat honey locust. The largest cbh was 10’8”. We > followed the stream, measuring a couple of fat sycamores along the way, > crossing the creek and up into the small ridge. Along this ridge is a huge > common hackberry( I made an earlier post about this tree). It measures > 12’3” x 114.2 which makes it a new northeast height record. I measured one > or two more trees before getting back to the truck. Another great day in > the woods! > > > > Here are the measurements for Cedar Hollow Preserve. > > > > Site Index > > Species CBH Height > > A Beech 2’11” 80.7 > > Bitternut Hickory 8’2” 99.9 > > Bitternut Hickory 6’9” 114.4 > > Black Locust 7’10” 91.7 > > Black Locust 4’8” 101.5 > > Black Walnut 5’6” 106.4 > > Chinkapin Oak 7’1” 87.8 > > Common Hackberry 12’3” 114.2 > > Crack Willow(3x) 15’8” 68.9 > > E Red Cedar 6’1” 48.0 > > Green Ash? 6’5” 109.9 > > Honey Locust 5’1” 90.5 > > N Red Oak 10’11” 100.5 > > N Red Oak 6’5” 110.4 > > Norway Maple 3’8” 94.9 > > Sugar Maple 5’6” 96.3 > > Sweet Cherry 4’5” 82.0 > > Sycamore 9’3” 121.9 > > Tulip Poplar 10’8” 124.5 > > Tulip Poplar 9’8” 134.0 > > White Oak N/A 91.4 > > > > Rucker Index > > Species CBH Height > > Tulip Poplar 9’8” 134.0 > > Sycamore 9’3” 121.9 > > Bitternut Hickory 6’9” 114.4 > > Common Hackberry 12’3” 114.2 > > N Red Oak 6’5” 110.4 > > Green Ash? 6’5” 109.9 > > Black Walnut 5’6” 106.4 > > Black Locust 4’8” 101.5 > > Sugar Maple 5’6” 96.3 > > Norway Maple 3’8” 94.9 > > RI 110.39 > > > > Here is a list of 12 x 100’s for the site. > > > > Species CBH Height > > Common Hackberry 12’3” 114.2 > > Sycamore 14’1” 102.6 > > Sycamore 19’5” 107.2 > > Sycamore 14’2” 121.5 > > > > The other sycamore to measure more than 14’ and just shy of 100’ is 17’2” x > 98.4. > > > > George > > > > > > <br > > > > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ Eastern Native Tree Society http://www.nativetreesociety.org Send email to [email protected] Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/entstrees?hl=en To unsubscribe send email to [email protected] -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
