Jesse Mazer wrote:

>Suppose there had already been a copy made, and the two of you 
>were sitting side-by-side, with the torturer giving you the 
>following options:
>A. He will flip a coin, and one of you two will get tortured 
>B. He points to you and says "I'm definitely going to torture 
>the guy sitting there, but while I'm sharpening my knives he 
>can press a button that makes additional copies of him as many 
>times as he can."
>Would this change your decision in any way? What if you are 
>the copy in this scenario, with a clear memory of having been 
>the "original" earlier but then pressing a button and finding 
>yourself suddenly standing in the copying chamber--would that 
>make you more likely to choose B?

That would be a more difficult decision. At this point, having experienced
escaping the torture, I might be more inclined to change my mind. That would
certainly be intellectually inconcistent, but psychologically
understandable.  But I still think I'd cboose (A).

Jonathan Colvin

Reply via email to