On 21 Aug 2011, at 14:43, Craig Weinberg wrote:
On Aug 21, 4:57 am, Bruno Marchal <marc...@ulb.ac.be> wrote:
Hmm... This is a point where I disagree with you Brent. Life is a
concept, I agree.
It's only 3-p fake. If it were truly fake we could not even have the
concept that there were anything at all like 'life' or 'living' to
consider fake or not. The concept that life is a fake concept is a
Its definition can only be conventional, at least
for a mechanist. It is 3-p reproduction, basically. I consider
cigarettes to be alive, with a very complex reproduction cycle
including transformation of the human brain.
That's why the mechanist position is critically flawed as a
cosmological-ontological TOE. It amputates the 1p definition of life -
which only marginally has to do with reproduction (I don't have kids,
so I'm disqualified from being 3-p 'alive'.) Life is about feeling
like you want to avoid dying, and that feeling is SIGNIFICANT.
This means only that you put consciousness or 1-p in life.
That is just a matter of definition.
I would not have consecrated my life to the study or consciousness if
it was to amputate the notion of first person, which, on the contrary,
I extend to number relations and program executions.
also about flourishing in whatever way you can - to feel like you are
thriving. I would go so far as to say that all organisms experience
this and that no inorganic materials experience this.
No materials at all experience things. Only persons, in a large sense
(not just humans, but animals, and angels, perhaps the plants, on some
That's not to say that inorganic materials experience nothing,
Which makes everything alive/conscious.
I know you do that. It is your panpsychism. I don't buy it.
hazard to guess that there is a bit of a blurred line with things like
crystal growth and virus transmission where the degree of
sensorimotive articulation approaches that of organic life - but my
sense is that it is likely more sterile and mathematical. More of a
monotonous drive in the sense of playing Solitaire or a turn based
computer game or weaving an endless patterned rug.
What you say informs me on Craig's first person, not on what is
matter, and what is consciousness.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at