On 3/20/2023 4:00 AM, Telmo Menezes wrote:
Meanwhile, back in reality:
(1) Do you understand the importance of testing machine learning
algorithms in out-of-corpus data? Do you understand the difference
between generalization and overfitting? This is the bread and butter
of machine learning. This is how ChatGPT was built. You are SUPER
EXCITED abou ChatGPT but you do not give a shit about the fundamentals
of machine learning? You think they no longer apply, while at the same
time cheerleading for its achievements? It's truly bizarre. I
approached this topic but you refuse to engage. I actually do
peer-review of ML papers and there is no way I (or anyone I work with)
would take in-corpus tests seriously. They often look absurdly good.
Will you take my trading algorithm offer?
(2) Human beings can form coherent memories and are capable of
long-term goals, strategy and slow thinking -- the Turing complete
kind. I have even seen people now claim that ChatGPT is good at
chess. It is incredibly good at chess given that it is a language
model trained with chess books amongst many other things, so it can
easily defeat naive players with chess recipes. It is capable of
navigating a min-max tree? Of course not, because it lacks recurrence.
It cannot possibly win against older generation AIs that do navigate
min-max trees and do defeat grand masters. So how do we combine the
two types of AI?
This seems like a crucial task for making really usable AI consultants.
You expect an AI be good at the things computers are good at and there
are plenty of computer modules to do mathematical inference and Bayesian
reasoning.
Brent
It looks like you don't care about any of this, instead you want to
convince me that ChatGPT is the answer to everything. Ok, maybe you
are right and I am crazy.
Telmo
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to everything-list+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/everything-list/4ab9b62f-e319-095e-77a8-92474b8debcc%40gmail.com.
