Thanks all and thank you Owain -- this is simplication towards clarification not a complication.

I'll repeat Creston's bit

You have your 4/4 measure
a.) the pulse is the quarter note.
b.) primary units at the eight -- 8/8
c.) extrametrical units are at the triplet -- 12/12

This 12/12 is what you are calling 12/8

In 12/8 the pulse is still in 4 -- all you've done is expand the tempo by a third to accommodate expanding the denominator by a third.

In answer to what does a twelfth note look like.

Creston again:

"...a 1/6 note triplet can be referred to (by the conductor) as a 'written quarter note' triplet, and a 1/12 note triplet as a 'written eight note' triplet.

He likens this kind of discourse (very astutely I think) with transposition -- that is the conductor speaks to the Bb trumpet player (eg) as 'concert D - your written E".

In other words nothing changes except 9/8 is now (properly) 1/3 longer than 9/12.

Simple.

Jerry


On 6-Jul-05, at 3:47 PM, Owain Sutton wrote:

It looks just like an 8th-note. The purpose of x/12, x/10 etc. is to allow changes of pulse, in non-triplet situations, with signatures such as 5/12. Yes, this could be indicated with a tempo change at the barline, but if the changes are every bar (as typical in Ferneyhough), x/12 etc. is the clearest system to use. And isn't at all complicated once you've familiarised yourself with it.




Gerald Berg

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to