On 19 Jun 2010 at 10:31, Howard Weiner wrote: > On 18.06.2010 21:56, John Howell wrote: > > > >> Here's the last two pages of the first viol part: > >> > >> http://dfenton.com/images/Capricornus-ColorationV1.png > >> > >> If you see anything there in regard to coloration that you think is > >> wrong in my interpretation, do let me know! > > > > OK, with that to look at, I do think I would interpret it > > differently, and actually more simply. I would probably keep the > > two minims as half notes (E5, A4), then treat the two black > > semibreves as actual imperfect semibreves worth 2 minims each (2 > > modern whole notes), and the first cadence note as a regular dotted > > semibreve (worth 3 minims). I didn't quite understand what you > > meant about the coloration changing the value of the notes BEFORE > > it, since that's something I've never come across. But this > > interpretation gives a very nice and very standard hemiola preceding > > the final cadence note, in a nice cross rhythm with each of the > > vocal parts, which are already in cross rhythms with each other. > > Exactly what I was saying! Now it looks right, except for two things: > you might want to recheck the rhythm of Bass 1 in measure 145,
I posted this in reply to John. Interpreting it "correctly" simply does not work. The original is here: http://dfenton.com/images/Capricornus-ColorationV4.png As I explained, someone had marked the semi-breves, and clearly the colored note in 145 crosses the semi-breve, but it's not able to fit as a full whole note. > and the > first ending should start after the f-sharp half note in soprano 2, > i.e., the final note of the phrase should clearly come on the beat in > both endings. That was just a layout issue. In the view in which I placed the endings, it was correct, but the stretching that occurred in page view made it not correct. I've fixed it in my current score, which I haven't uploaded. > Concerning the extended final measures of the various sections, I > would do one of two things: either rebar using smaller measures > throughout the piece, which would automatically solve the problem and > can actually be justified for music of this late date, I'm really against this, as it causes all sorts of problems. I recently wrote about this score: http://tearesofthemuses.com/Editions/Scores/Sch%fctz-AufDemGebirge/ ...which you can see in the "original" from the modern edition, with barlines at the semi-breve, and in what I consider the preferred notation, with barlines at the breve. We performed it in the past from the first, and we had major problems. With the rebarring to match the sources, it worked much more smoothly. Of course, that is earlier, and is also in an antique style even for its time, but I don't think leaving the note values alone and adding extra barlines like that helps. > or leave out > the "new" time signature and add a mensurstrich to divide the extended > measure into a "full" measure and a "half" measure, which would get > rid of the anomaly of having music in duple meter with a triple-meter > time signature. I've considered doing that, but doing so would cause so many layout issues, I've decided to stay with what I've got. I'm not sure I understand what you mean by the "duple meter" -- it's not in duple meter. It's 3 beats of dotted whole, it just happens in that measure that there's a hemiola, and it vaguely looks like it's duple. If you change the meter to something that fits the coloration, then, I believe, you're missing the whole point of the coloration, which is that it's rhythmically at war with the flow of the meter that's been established. -- David W. Fenton http://dfenton.com David Fenton Associates http://dfenton.com/DFA/ _______________________________________________ Finale mailing list [email protected] http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
