On Wed, 2007-05-23 at 19:14 +1000, Dion Gillard wrote: > I think there's another issue here. > > Many of those who voted +1, aren't on the initial list of committers > in the proposal. > > Also, many current commons committers aren't on the proposed list. > > It seems that we're not voting on that specific proposal, rather just > the idea to move, and that a lot of people are being disenfranchised > by not being listed. > > Wouldn't it be better if the initial list came from the svn acl? >
Dion, Just speaking for myself I intentionally did not want to add my name to the list of committers to show my disapproval of the proposal, but at the same I did not feel my involvement in the rest of Commons besides maintenance of HttpClient 3.x codeline was significant enough to justify a -1 vote. Oleg > On 5/23/07, Niall Pemberton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 5/8/07, Henri Yandell <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Sadly a bit too late to make the next board meeting I suspect. > > > > > > However, here's a vote for Commons to officially request that it move to > > > TLP. > > > > > > http://wiki.apache.org/jakarta-commons/TLPResolution > > > > > > Please add your name if you're a Commons developer and haven't added > > > your name yet. > > > > > > [ ] +1 I support the proposal > > > [ ] +0 I don't care > > > [ ] -1 I'm opposed to the proposal because... > > > > > > Voting will close in one week. > > > > Quick summary of this thread 28 Votes for (23 binding), 4 against (3 > > binding). Seems to me that those objecting don't seem to have > > pursuaded people to change their vote. At what point do we decide on a > > result? > > > > Votes +1 (* indicates binding) > > ======== > > 1. Henri Yandell(*) > > 2. Dennis Lundberg(*) > > 3. Mladen Turk(*) > > 4. Torsten Curdt(*) > > 5. Oliver Heger(*) > > 6. Robert Burrell Donkin(*) > > 7. Stephen Colebourne(*) > > 8. Daniel F. Savarese(*) > > 9. Martin Cooper(*) > > 10. Mark Thomas(*) > > 11. Niall Pemberton(*) > > 12. Stefan Bodewig(*) > > 13. Phil Steitz(*) > > 14. Jörg Schaible(*) > > 15. Jean-Frederic(*) > > 16. Henning Schmiedehausen(*) > > (conditional on The TLP proposal matching the template) > > 17. Nick Burch > > 18. Davanum Srinivas(*) > > 19. Thomas Vandahl > > 20. Oliver Zeigermann(*) > > 21. Rony G. Flatscher(*) > > 22. Scott Eade(*) > > 23. Yegor Kozlov > > 24. Luc Maisonobe > > 25. Mario Ivankovits(*) > > 26. Roland Weber(*) > > 27. Andrew Oliver(*) > > (think this was a vote for, voted -1 to Commons=Jakarta) > > 28. Jesse Kuhnert > > > > Added themselves to the TLP Proposal but didn't vote(?) > > ==================================================== > > 1. Jochen Wiedmann > > 2. Martin van den Bemt(*) > > 3. Matt Benson > > 4. Rory Winston(*) > > 5. Joerg Pietschmann > > > > Objections / Votes -1 > > ===================== > > 1. Petar Tahchiev > > - sees no direct benfits for Commons > > 2. Ted Husted(*) > > - Strike Java from resolution or don't hijack "Commons" Name > > 3. Simon Kitching(*) > > - Will erect walls we took down > > - like Ted doesn't want java to monopolise "commons" name > > 4. Danny Angus(*) > > - preserve the Jakarta brand > > - Wants Jkarata==Jakarta Commons > > - thinks Commons should sort out Jakarta problems > > > > Bile & Nonsense > > =============== > > Jean Carlo Salas > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
