On Nov 24, 12:11 pm, Sean T Evans <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
> Hash: SHA1
> If the argument is that we shouldn't change things that the users are
> most familiar with, the argument could be extended to say that all
> links, no matter where, must be underlined, and should keep the default
> blue/red/purple color scheme that we're all familiar with. While I
> realize this is taking the argument to an extreme, I think it
> illustrates the point that people adjust to changes from the familiar
> constantly and, usually, without any conscious effort. It always bothers
> me when arguments are made that cast our theoretical users as not only
> "less savvy" but darn near idiotic.
>
It's not as far fetched an example as one might think. I've heard the
word "accessibility" thrown around quite a bit regarding the buttons,
and find it humorous, as it's a selective use of the term. Links in
admin are a perfect example. Ever try to configure a plugin that
requires an external link? It's almost impossible to discern it, and
I have a pretty decent monitor and good eye sight, not to mention I'm
not color blind. There is a logical foundation for why default links
are styled a certain way. However, a decision was made for aesthetic
reasons to ignore these rules. To me, that sets a precedent, and all
elements are fair game for change, assuming there is some valid
argument for making them.
If we are going to argue for accessibility, then we should apply that
across the board, not subjectively based on the personal tastes of a
few who care to voice their preference.
Regarding the buttons, I personally do not like to style them for a
web site, because of the nuances between browsers, and because casual
viewers should immediately be able to recognize what is at hand, and
get to where they are going/trying to get. However, the admin is not
designed for the casual visitor, so therefore the argument doesn't
hold as much water. When we were still employing BluePrint, it
shipped with a buttons plugin, and we dabbled with using it, however,
there was disagreement on what should be a button and what should just
be a text link, and it never was picked up, however, there was never
any argument about styling the buttons. Just a small historical note.
>From a personal standpoint, I primarily use FF on a Mac, but do not
like the native bubble buttons, so having styling wouldn't bother me
in the least, simply as long as the actions are obvious.
~miklb
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/habari-dev
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
