William, there we are. All the confusion came up because Engelbert Schmid offers that extra slide(s) for the E/A conversion. The main problem is not the tuning, but to be used enough to use this E/A horn with the asked precision. It might be problematic to finger different than you are used to do, but hear things as they should sound. Do you remember talking with these band horns who used the Eb-crook inserted to the tuning slide. Their output Bb remains a "c" for them. But are we going the path backwards ? Schmid did that, as he - a stubborn Bb-user except the written g below staff - had fingering problems for the E tonality because of his super strong affinity to the Bb-horn. And as he is a superb engineer, he constructed a horn to fit his needs. Well, if one leaves the orchestra & plays just occasionally here & there, he has time enough & pencils as well, to prepare his E part.
For a horn in F#/H ? Isn“t it a bit sharper regarding tone character ??? Sorry, we might be fixed too much to the F/Bb, but in daily use of F/Bb and Bb/high F for certain pieces we are on certain roads and we do not want a navigator device placed on the horn, perhaps. It is much simpler, to use the main horn as it is, than looking for another special for this and again another special for that piece. Developing ones own software seems to work much better than plumbing around. O.K. the plumbers need also some income. There is also a horn, built by a most prominent maker, which can be tuned in so many different combinations, that you might end up with a horn playing in F on both sides, perhaps, but you can convert it to F#/Ab or D/G. My goodness, you have to own a stationary shop for that many pencils & erasers you need to make up your part ! Some players forget the pencil or the markings, - and the desaster happen. This is not funny, not for the audience, not for the conducter & finally not for the player, who might be fired after several such desasters. "If you go through fire, you need a fireproof suit or a fire extinguisher." A most elegant tuxedo would not help you there nor would nice words clean the left overs. We live in a world requiring perfection in music or other entertainment also. Why making things complicate, if simple solutions are approved since very long. We should not turn the clock backwards. Sorry, to ask you, you did never comment my recommendation, to use the F-side a bit more up in the horns compass, a bit more up than usual, to solve the E-issue. I have my own experience with different tuned horns, which were in principal mere standard, but the third valve was rising the pitch up for a full tone, making the horn a F/Bb & G/C. This was fun. Try the Schubert Octet op.166 g-jumps for three different regions. Play G-major with such a horn, heavenly. But not for our repertory with the heavy pieces: Heldenleben, Bruckner 8, Ring, Strauss operas , etc. but fine for Mozart & Haydn & chamber works. I used it for 4 years for everything. +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Am 30.11.2009 um 22:33 schrieb [email protected]: > Something else to consider - a desire to play an E piece on a true E horn > or a cleaner transposition is in no way indicative that the person cannot > play it on an F horn in E. > > Let's face the truth - there are many avenues to get from point A to point > B - and some work for some and some work for others. We've established that > some people want to play a piece in E on an E horn, an F#/B horn (even > Schmid himself has suggested this before so I'm not the first). If you can > perform the piece well and musically and _not miss_, WHO CARES. > > I frankly prefer playing an E piece on an F#/B horn. So what. I've > performed it that way, competed on E pieces that way, and have won/placed in > competitions that way. > > All I did (just like my tuning method) was offer yet another avenue. > > How many times have new ideas or new methods been squashed in the realm of > music because it wasn't tradition? If we were truly sticklers for tradition > why would we ever touch Mahler. > > -William > _______________________________________________ > post: [email protected] > unsubscribe or set options at > https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/hpizka%40me.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
