Dear William, I understand your arguments regarding
"That's why I also play along the partials wherever I can and wherever it's in tune. In other words, if there is a section that is all open on the Bb side, I'll keep it all open. ", but this does not work with "cantilena" passages, but works well for triads etc. But this can be done with most fixed finger positions, no matter on Bb- side or F-side. And there are more finger movements on the Bb-side than on the F-side, if the piece is in E or Eflat or in F. The F-side requires 4 finger movements in the lower octave (from the written c1 just one ledger line below staff to the written c2 in the 2nd space from top) (d, f, a, b-nat.) and just three finger movements in the upper octave (f, a, b-nat) If the piece is in E, the 2nd valve is pressed down permanently except for steps 4 & 7 of the lower octave, same in the upper octave (b-nat, c# & d# all on 2nd). So you are required to activate additional keys for c# (12), e(open), g# (23), a#(1) in the lower octave, but just for e (0), g# (23) a# (1) in the upper octave. Total seven additional movements for the two octaves, besides the nearly permanently pressed 2nd valve. The Bb-side requires the 2nd valve be pressed for B-nat, c#, e, f#, g#, b-nat (6-times), but requires additional finger movement for c#(23), d#(1), f#(12), g#(23), a# (1) in the lower octave and fixed 2nd valve for B-nat., c#, e, f#, g#, b-nat-top in the upper octave plus additional finger movement for c#(23), d#(1), g#(23 - otherwise too flat mostly), a#(1). A total of nine additional finger movements for two octaves. If you use a horn in E, you will use the same number of additional finger movements as on the F-side. Why then to tune the horn to E ? By pressing the 2nd valve most of the time, the horn is tuned to E allready. And I cannot see how the E-scale on the F-horn should be less smooth than an E-flat scale. The E-flat scale would count only, if you up-tune your horn to F# first & play the E part as if it were an E-flat part. But the valve movements would remain the same, also in numbers. ############################################################################ Am 20.07.2010 um 08:27 schrieb [email protected]: > Depends on the piece. For something like an Opera I would play it > normally. In a solo setting, I will do whatever I can to make it > easier on myself. > > It's also not only about finger breaking, but it's about smoothness. > No matter how good you are, an E scale will never be as smooth as an > Eb scale. > > Smoothness means the least amount of valve changes possible. That's > why I also play along the partials wherever I can and wherever it's > in tune. In other words, if there is a section that is all open on > the Bb side, I'll keep it all open. > > -William > _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
