This is for the most part incorrect.

A wish I could construct an HTML table to demonstrate this but I'm sure the 
list isn't that sophisticated.

Nevertheless I can construct a list of changes from one set of valves to the 
other

open to:

1 valve - 1 change
2 valves - 2 changes (must be coordinated together)
3 valves - 3 changes (must again be coordinate together)
4 valves - 4 changes

Seems simple enough, right?

What about when we go from 1 valve to 2:

1st valve to trigger - 2 changes (1st open, trigger down)
1st valve to 2 and 3 - 3 changes (1st open, 2 and 3 down)

Or what about from 1st to 2nd valve?

1st valve to open, 2nd to closed, two changes

BUT, WE'RE FORGETTING SOMETHING (and hopefully some of you on the list have 
seen the fatal flaw above).

You always argue that the human software isn't perfect, and in that case there 
WILL be minor coordination issues to deal with which would change something 
like 1st to 2nd into this litany of valve changes:

1st to open
all valves open for a millisecond
2nd to closed

OR

1st to open WHILE 2nd is closing
1st and 2nd open at the same time
2nd open 

Or what about 1st to 23?

You could have all 1,2,3 down at the same time for a split second
You could have all open for a split second
You could have 1 and 2 or 1 and 3 together for a split second

And, if you throw the trigger in, you get twice as many chances for split 
second 'mistakes' that will throw you off.

Eb's changes are mostly 1 valve at a time. Meaning its mostly 1 and 2 and most 
of your changes are going to be from open to 1 or 1 to 1 and 2 or 1 and 2 to 1. 
More infrequent are you going to have 1 and 2 together (which can be subbed for 
3). You'll probably never encounter a 1 to 2 like you will frequently in E horn 
on F.

By your own logic about 'human software' not being perfect - wouldn't it make 
more sense to make it as simple as possible? If you're on a piece in E, then 
play it on an E horn (or a horn so you can transpose to Eb) if possible. 

Saxophones (and other button pushing instruments) have to deal with the 
limitations of the human hand and coordination all the time. Piano is another 
perfect example. Why do you think pianists spend hours finding the perfect 
fingerings for passages and writing them down? Why do you think ideal 
fingerings are found in most difficult piano works actually engraved with the 
part? Why do you think saxophones or oboes or flutes have so many different 
alternate/trill fingerings? They're not for show or spits and giggles. They 
have a use. 

It's strange how violins, harps, all of the woodwinds, and pianos spend time 
discussing and even writing in hand movements (and have centuries of trial and 
error on this) and horn players just ignore it. It's never a bad idea to get 
advice from other instruments. If we supposedly have such a difficult 
instrument, wouldn't it be pretty dumb to not listen to any idea that could 
make our lives simpler?

As a side story, when I was about 14 years old I had this strange question in 
my mind about snapping fingers. I could snap pretty well and pretty loudly, but 
I wondered where the actual 'snap' came from. So, I recorded a few snaps on a 
computer. When we listen to a snap it pretty much sounds instantaneous, doesn't 
it? It sounds like there's just one pop and it's all over. However, if you slow 
it down, you find out that there is another chapter to the story. If you slow 
the sound down enough, you'll hear a 'swish' followed by a 'pop'. This is 
because when most people snap the fingers initially slip past each other 
causing a swish, and the pop is caused by the finger landing against the palm 
and a pretty good force. Curiously enough, I applied this idea to a few brass 
instruments for valve combinations - and the more valves that changed the more 
you would hear several clicks as you slowed it down. This became even more 
evident with woodwind instruments. The valves would almost 
 never land within the same millisecond - and more often than not you'd always 
get at least a couple of milliseconds difference between 'clicks'. 

A split second may be trivial - but it's more important than you realize.

-William

 

 


 

 

-----Original Message-----
From: Hans Pizka <[email protected]>
To: The Horn List <[email protected]>
Sent: Tue, Jul 20, 2010 4:37 pm
Subject: Re: [Hornlist] von Krufft Sonata


Dear William,



I understand your arguments regarding



"That's why I also play along the partials wherever I can and wherever  

it's in tune.

In other words, if there is a section that is all open on the Bb side,  

I'll keep it all open. ",



but this does not work with

"cantilena" passages, but works well for triads etc.



But this can be done with most fixed finger positions, no matter on Bb- 

side or F-side.



And there are more finger movements on the Bb-side than on the F-side,  

if the piece

is in E or Eflat or in F.



The F-side requires 4 finger movements in the lower octave (from the  

written c1 just

one ledger line below staff to the written c2 in the 2nd space from  

top) (d, f, a, b-nat.)

and just three finger movements in the upper octave (f, a, b-nat)



If the piece is in E, the 2nd valve is  pressed down permanently  

except for steps 4 & 7 of

the lower octave, same in the upper octave (b-nat, c# & d# all on  

2nd). So you are required to activate

additional keys for c# (12), e(open), g# (23), a#(1) in the lower  

octave, but  just for e (0), g# (23)

a# (1) in the upper octave. Total seven additional movements for the  

two octaves, besides the

nearly permanently pressed 2nd valve.



The Bb-side requires the

2nd valve be pressed for  B-nat, c#, e,  f#, g#, b-nat (6-times), but  

requires additional finger

movement for c#(23), d#(1), f#(12), g#(23), a# (1) in the lower octave  

and

fixed 2nd valve for B-nat., c#, e, f#, g#, b-nat-top in the upper octave

plus additional finger movement for c#(23), d#(1), g#(23 - otherwise  

too flat mostly), a#(1).

A total of nine additional finger movements for two octaves.



If you use a horn in E, you will use the same number of additional  

finger movements as  on

the F-side.



Why then to tune the horn to E ? By pressing the 2nd valve most of the  

time, the horn is

tuned to E allready.



And I cannot see how the E-scale on the F-horn should be less smooth  

than an E-flat

scale. The E-flat scale would count only, if you up-tune your horn to  

F# first & play the

E part as if it were an E-flat part. But the valve movements would  

remain the same, also

in numbers.





############################################################################



Am 20.07.2010 um 08:27 schrieb [email protected]:



> Depends on the piece. For something like an Opera I would play it  

> normally. In a solo setting, I will do whatever I can to make it  

> easier on myself.

>

> It's also not only about finger breaking, but it's about smoothness.  

> No matter how good you are, an E scale will never be as smooth as an  

> Eb scale.

>

> Smoothness means the least amount of valve changes possible. That's  

> why I also play along the partials wherever I can and wherever it's  

> in tune. In other words, if there is a section that is all open on  

> the Bb side, I'll keep it all open.

>

> -William

>



_______________________________________________

post: [email protected]

unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com


 
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to