>> Of course not. That's an example of the reason that I don't find ADSP >> useful (as opposed to manually vetted discard lists.) There's no way to >> tell whether the party publishing discardable understands what they're >> saying. >> > > And likewise there is no way to tell whether the party implementing discard > lists understand what they're doing. IMHO, we should stay away from assuming > the presence or absence of a given level of expertise of the mail admins on > this earth.
There's a fairly key difference you're missing here. For ADSP, each domain publishes what it thinks is its own policy, so if you look at a million domains, you have to guess about the competence of a million mail system managers. On the other hand, if you use one or two published drop lists, you can afford to look at them and choose ones whose administrators are competent, without having to individually vet each entry. R's, John _______________________________________________ NOTE WELL: This list operates according to http://mipassoc.org/dkim/ietf-list-rules.html
