Hi 2015-03-15 8:33 GMT-03:00 Dan Ackroyd <dan...@basereality.com>:
> On 15 March 2015 at 06:59, Marcio Almada <marcio.w...@gmail.com> wrote: > > Hi, > > > > I received some requests to update the RFC with more information about BC > > breaks + possible minor adjustments regarding dynamic function calls. > > > Please can you stop abusing the RFC process? > > This RFC is attempting to change the language. You received the > information about the BC breaks weeks ago, they aren't new items that > you just heard about for the first time today.. You opened the voting > and then closed it immediately when you realised the vote wasn't going > to sail through. > > There is no abuse. This is not true, I truly received a suggestion from Bob Weiland and decided to consider it. 4:3 is not a sign that a voting will pass or not, it's only 7 votes and we usually get ~52 votes during a 14 days voting period. > You're now making changes to the RFC and proposing to re-open voting > on the same day. How are people meant to have time to read and think > about the changes? > > It's a **minor** change, as said before. This was the most prudent attitude. > It's also going to be impossible for people to try the patch out, or > to measure it for performance hit. > > Performance has never been an issue with this RFC. You probably meant "bc break" not "performance hit", and the suggested change about dynamic calls Bob did, if accepted by, is a minor change that will actually reduce the BC breaks not enlarge it. > The problem this RFC fixes is not a big enough problem to justify > making decisions about the language at the last minute, particularly > as the last version of the RFC I read breaks a whole load of valid > code. > > A lot of people tell me the opposite. I listened to your opinion many times and disagreed with it. Please don't express your disagreement with the RFC by mixing it with false accusations towards me. There is a huge gap between both attitudes. The disagreement is ok, but the false accusations coming from you make me sad. > cheers > Dan > Marcio
