I have a similar setup to yours, except ADSL not dialup.

I don't think you need to have a rdr statement for the GRE unless you
are running a pptp server on another internal box (I don't have it and
what you want works fine for me).

I allow everything out by default and I have a rule that allows GRE from
any to any back in.

This allows me to connect from my two windows pc's to a pptp server at
work.

Regards,

Adam

-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Wednesday, 14 January 2004 11:42 AM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: IPFilter 3.4.33pre1, GRE/PPTP client behind firewall

I understand this issue has been hashed again and again and again
hundreds of times... but after
searching the archives, I am still stumped.

Situation:
I have a Sun Ultra 5 (Solaris 9) as a dialup
router/firewall/server/kitchen sink/etc. at home, which
maintains a dialup modem connection to my ISP.  We'll say its Internet
address is 64.64.64.64 (dev sppp0) at the moment.
I also have an internal LAN, 192.168.0.0/24.  My Sun box's IP on this
LAN is 192.168.0.1 (dev hme0), and it is the default
route for all internal LAN boxes (it also runs Sun's DHCP server).

I have a laptop on this LAN.  My laptop has RedHat Linux 9 with
PPTP software installed, and that works great (when it's given a real
Internet address).
It is the ONLY client in my LAN which needs to do ANYTHING with PPTP or
GRE.  It needs to connect to the
corporate VPN server (which is on a public Internet IP), we'll call it
12.12.12.12.
My laptop's IP is 192.168.0.45.

I understand I can set up a rdr using IPNat so GRE packets coming from
12.12.12.12 to my dialup modem can be
redirected to my laptop's IP (192.168.0.45) using a rule like:
rdr sppp0 0.0.0.0/0 port 0 -> 192.168.0.45 port 0 gre

I am not sure if this works, because the following scenario exists when
I try to make a PPTP connection:

My laptop sends packets to the corporate VPN server (12.12.12.12) with
protocol=47 (GRE), however
Source IP=192.168.0.45, Dest IP=12.12.12.12.  That's fine, except my Sun
box continues to send that packet
out the modem as Source=192.168.0.45, Dest=12.12.12.12 !
It does not rewrite the Source IP of the outbound GRE packet.  Are there
any rules I should add to enable this?

Note that I determined this by use of Solaris's "snoop" program.  I
noticed that TCP NAT'ed packets for the port 1723
connection appeared in "snoop" as bearing the destination/source IP of
the Sun box's dialup modem IP, rather than the
laptop's internal IP.  The IP packets bearing protocol "47" all said
source IP of 192.168.0.45, so I assume that means
it sent the packet out the modem as such.



Also for the record, I have basic TCP/UDP NAT'ing for all boxes in my
internal LAN, using the following IPNat rule:
map sppp0 192.168.0.0/24 -> 0.0.0.0/32 portmap tcp/udp 20000:30000


Thank you very much!

Reply via email to